-
@chiefbeef123: Theres a complete difference between killing in self defense (the doctor held up a scalpel to joel and said he would let him take her) and in the defense of others (what the doctor was ...
-
@chiefbeef123: She wasnt okay. She was suffering from PTSD bad which was what the barn scene was for. I think you can open her notebook and read more about what she was dealing with mentally. And that...
-
@thepanzini: The fungal infection taking control of a body isnt unbelievable or unrealistic. New diseases are being born all the time. Old microbes are mutating all the time.Having a health bar comes ...
-
It would be ironic though if the doctor did give a shot to everyone thinking he did develop a vaccine (for a fungus) and since there is no trials they all just had a heart attack and died due to the v...
-
@diamond_lime: So we are just back to poor writing of the doctor being a magic man that can find a vaccine (for a fungus) that millions upon millions of others couldnt over the course of 20 years and ...
-
@plan6: Jackson, the town that still has brushes with different factions.... is that the sword you want to die on?
-
@thepanzini: Because joel is not a scientist. He doesnt have a clue. Niether does any other firefly. They even say that doctor was the only one... well no duh he was the only one... because he was del...
-
@thepanzini: The only reason they were looking for a cure is because a deranged doctor had some idealistic notion that he could do it instead of accepting reality. They really are no better than the s...
-
@plan6: If you cant think critically about the different factions then maybe you shouldn't comment?FEDRA was still taking in refugees and guarding the walls. They were still clearing the infected. The...
-
Closest thing to the good guys was FEDRA. They were the ones in charge of building the walls. Taking in refugees. Passing out rations. Killing infected. Enforcing the law. Were they corrupt? Probably...
-
@thepanzini: You lose all credibility when you say the fireflies were the closest thing to good. They were an extremist terrorist group. Or are you forgetting the firefly the spray painted liars in th...
-
@diamond_lime: I havent stated it specifically but that's the exact reason it was going to be murder.@arciteeNo, joel is doing CPR on Ellie when the fire flies find them. He gets knocked out. Owen run...
-
@diamond_lime: Yeah. We dont see anything from Leah, Danny or the one with the hat. I forget his name.Nora, Manny and Mel definitely feel justified in her actions and state he should have gotten worse...
-
@diamond_lime: You're partly right. It was prolonged and sadistic. Extremely contrived in order for it to take place too.Her friends, however, did sympathize with her. Mel even said something like thi...
-
@justabard: I explicitly stated I didnt realize the same people of animations, which you tried using in your point, were the same people in charge of characters. Because they're not. Regardless if you...
-
@justabard: I didnt realize the animators are the same people in charge of character creation and story :-/
-
@diamond_lime: You can easily write a story that's not contrived. We all agree ellie going to SLC makes sense, right? She probably wrote a note to joel stating such which is why hes right behind her. ...
-
@justabard: Forcing things is not easy and resources are limited.
-
@justabard: I edited the post you quoted to add a second part.As for your post, youre completely right. Changing every character to a white male wouldn't change the story or enjoyment. That's why I sa...
-
@justabard: I didn't count them. It was off recollection. And on M y 2nd play through I found more. But that's besides the point. The point is, it starts feeling like they spend so much time forcing i...
Log in to comment