The constant praise for Red Dead Redemption in the gaming community just shows how little people expect from westerns. Like they've only seen Sergio Leone and Unforgiven (and Tarantino's last films I guess).
Before I got into westerns these last few years, I thought Red Dead Redemption was alright. Now? After watching John Ford, Nicholas Ray, Sam Peckinpah? Red Dead Redemption just sucks!
VincentVendetta's comments