@awkwardl0ser: Clearly the staff doesn't agree with you that it was "a very good game"
I don't know if I'd have given it worst game, but it's a bad game that took a huge steaming dump on a beloved franchise, so I understand why they did. Andromeda was bad enough that I didn't put it on my personal list even though I played fewer than 10 new games this year.
edit: what actually seems crazy is Horizon not making the list. Didn't finish it myself, but everyone on staff who played it when it came out seemed to like it an awful lot.
walruspete's comments