Not what I would have listed, but to each his own.

Great list ! I didn't play Forza though. Man , I really need to play Banjo N&B again.

I'd put ilomilo in there(even though its an IOS game as well) . I really like puzzle games and it hit the spot. The music is amazing , and difficulty was just right and fair .

Red Dead Redemption: Very cool game, really enjoyed the experience.
Tiger Woods PGA Tour 12: The Masters: One of the best if not the best golf game I've ever played.
Dead Space: Loved every minute. I need to play the second one.
College Hoops 2k8: I still play this bastard.
Assassin's Creed 1 and 2: Brotherhood brought my love to an end. It was great while it lasted.
Let's go six:
Mass Effect 2: Played and looked great, bought it again for the PC.

i have 215 games total-arcade retail comb ined so im doing 25

1. test drive unlimited 2
2. goldeneye reloaded-also makes my top 25 wii games at 1
3. cod 4
4. gta iv
5. saints row 2
6. saints row
7. driver san francisco
8. nascar 2011
9. wwe 2011
10. quantum of solace 007\
11. perfect darkxbla
12. duke nukem 3d
13. mortal kombat arcade collection
14. sonics ultimate genesis collection-sure gave me a reason to let my genesis sit aside
15. blood stone
16. pgr 4
17. forza motorsport 3
18. blur
19. dirt 2
20. gears of war
21. gears of war 2
22. dead rising
23. dead rising 2 case 0
24. dead rising 2 case west

and finally --- la noire

now a top 5 worst games i have less of those so i do 5

1. perfect dark zero
2. race pro
3. import tuner challenge
4. nfs hot pursuit -no custom race mode kills this one on the spot
5. halo 3 --- spear me cause this should really be an xbox 1 game cause it does not look like a 360 game, -nor does it play like one either ,

Good list, but why are you posting it on a game website if it's a list for casual gamers?

Meh.

Good list.