thai_jedi's Project Gotham Racing 4 (Xbox 360) review

PGR 4 review

With automotive monsters like Forza Motorsport 2 and DiRT nicely filling their respective niches, you might wonder what there is left to do with the racing genre.

As fun as it can be, Project Gotham Racing 4 doesn't seem to know either.

Making an Impression
At first glance, every race in PGR 4 is a stylish mix of simulation precision, arcade excitement, and egomaniacal showboating. Showing skill on the asphalt in any form earns you Kudos--everything from peel-outs and powerslide drifts to expert cornering and air time can be strung together as long as you don't tag a wall too hard in the process, and each sequence is rated from one to five stars so you know precisely how cool you really are.

The Kudos you earn in every mode can be spent on a range of unlockable goodies such as unlockable cars and tracks but they can also make the difference between winning and losing a championship series in the long Gotham Career mode. Style is almost as important as form as you claw your way up from the amateur ranks, and the historically conservative AI has finally learned to express itself a little bit.

Mix and Match
What's most unusual about PGR 4 is that the physics engine is strangely uneven. Slam into the right rear corner of an opponent's sled and he'll barely flinch, let alone spin into the wall as you'd expect. Contrast that to the fact that if you fail to feather the throttle as you come out of an arcade-style drift, you'll spend precious seconds just spinning your wheels.

Some racing enthusiasts will love the atypical mash-up; others, especially car tweakers and purists, will probably find it maddening. The disappointing audio is also lamentable as is the damage modeling that appears to be merely cosmetic. Still, once you wrap your head around the quirks, the game does deliver some thrills. The unfortunate thing is that the whole experience never truly comes together.

Balancing Act
There are plenty of offline modes to keep you entertained but the online mode is rather lacking, despite some bells and whistles like the ability to categorize and upload photos for others to vote on. There are only four rather unimaginative event types, and one of those starts off locked.

All in all, PGR 4 is enjoyable enough that it warrants a look but it just doesn't play to its strengths well enough to stand toe-to-toe with the current champions of the next-generation racing world.

PROS: Beautiful weather effects, over 120 vehicles, lots of tracks and offline events.
CONS: Lousy collision and damage models, unconvincing motorcycles, dearth of online events.
1 Comments
Posted by Godzilla_Sushi

If by bad damage models you mean no damage model then yeah, I'd agree.

I don't know if I'd agree with you about collision detection, since it does work as it should. It's a little floaty but overall it never really fails in my opinion. For this kind of game, I can understand why you don't hit another car and they just spin out. There is so much contact involved during a race that anything less would be frustrating and difficult for the player.

But nice review! Just wanted to comment!

Other reviews for Project Gotham Racing 4 (Xbox 360)

    Throroughly Entertaining, But Not Outstanding 0

    The Project Gotham Series has entertained me since I picked up PGR2 way back on the original XBOX. PGR2 was one of the first few games to utilize online play through Xbox Live, and it did it fantastically well. When I got PGR3 at the Xbox 360 release I was pumped for more fun like that online. The game stayed awesome for single play throughout the arcade mode, but the online championships killed the casual fun that PGR2 had going for it online.PGR4 has a high quality single player mode. In fact,...

    1 out of 1 found this review helpful.

    Forza is much better. 0

    The game is fun, don't get me wrong, but moving from PGR 3 to PGR 4 is quite a huge change, first off, the got rid of the feature that allowed the player to walk around their virtual garage and look at all the cars that they own (Which if you're a car enthusiast like myself, is really awesome) infarct, you don't even own any cars, you just unlock them and have the ability to use them in different races. They've also added motorcycles to the game, I will say that it is fun driving a motorcycle i...

    1 out of 1 found this review helpful.

This edit will also create new pages on Giant Bomb for:

Beware, you are proposing to add brand new pages to the wiki along with your edits. Make sure this is what you intended. This will likely increase the time it takes for your changes to go live.

Comment and Save

Until you earn 1000 points all your submissions need to be vetted by other Giant Bomb users. This process takes no more than a few hours and we'll send you an email once approved.