So Bonnie is running through the field and hides behind a tractor. Someone slowly walks up to you, but you hit them with your rebar. It turns out it's Dee (I think that's her name?) and everyone gets all sad. But when I first played that bit, I screwed up and didn't hit the prompt in time. The camera cuts to the black silhouette with the flashlight punching me in the face and I get a game over.

Why the fuck would Dee punch me in the face? I knew she was mad at me for screwing around with her husband, but when I played it again and hit her successfully, she was being a huge bitch about me hitting her. She was planning to do the same thing to me apparently! What's the deal here?

Dee was kind of shady. I wouldn't be surprised if she had manipulative tendencies, and indeed was planning to do something to Bonnie, even if she made her feel guilty in death.

Yep, same thing happened to me. Somewhat ruined the moment where you're meant to feel bad for killing her when she was about to do the same to you.

Exactly how I felt. I was waiting for the character to get a bit closer before I hit the prompt, but ended up being a fraction of a second too late and was bludgeoned in the face with a flashlight. Kinda took me out of the moment when I killed Dee with the rebar since she had just killed me a minute before.

Oh wow that sucks, the first season did a better job of keeping you out of scenarios like that.

This is the one part in the DLC I didn't really like. In the first season, the game did a really good job of hiding certain things from you but here, there is no other outcome. She either hits you and you die or you hit her and kill her which isn't really an option at all if you obviously want to continue with the story and no matter what you say to her, she's still just convinced you did it to be with Leland.

Bonnie was an ex-drug addict and i think the whole 'You Are Dead' screen there is just meant to put you in her shoes. You could say she was twitchy from withdrawals or whatever and she would have whacked anyone who snuck up on her.

It's lazy i know but that's my assessment on what the writers were going for. Although I'm pretty sure if someone slowly creeped up on me at night, with a flashlight, and without saying a word i would have attacked them too.

Oh wow, it seriously just gives you a game over if you don't hit her? The seems super lazy.

yh that was odd it felt lazy the whole dlc felt kinda rushed

So do you ever find out what's in the bag? I'm guessing not, unless I missed it.

@kishinfoulux: It's referenced in Shel's story. It's food and medicine stolen from Shel's group.

Now I know what would've happened. I felt pretty shitty and in retrospect, thought I should have waited a bit before insta-clicking on the prompt. Good to know the bitch had it coming.

And probably the missing flashlight as well, which Dee was carrying when Bonnie smashes her face in.