That is the question. I have now seen a few people play through episode 4 and I was delighted to see how people struggled with their decisions and how quick they were to change their minds about Ben when they had just been cursing his stupidity and planning his future death. Even if episode 5 somehow turns out to be a weak episode I feel that the game delivered on making you care about your choices even if events didn't play out as differently as you might have thought they would. The point was how you felt in that moment.
ME3 has been talked to death on how people felt their choices in previous "episodes" would have made more of an impact in the end, but I think it's worth pointing out that people were more upset over how little their choices mattered compared to the Walking Dead and their similar set up.
Why is this? Are your choices better presented, the differences more impactful, or do you simply care more about the characters?