I couldn't believe it when he was going on about English accents. Using an English accent for some characters is not specific to this game, not even to video games. Would he rather them all speak Polish, or some made up language? Fuck.
Also, when he is talking about the "systems" being off, he is simply flat out wrong. The example he is using is from Bernard Loredo's mansion during Chapter 1, when you arrive in Flotsam. He asks you to come to his place at night. I can CONFIRM from 3 playthroughs that Midnight is an acceptable time to come to his house. I can't believe how he uses this as a negative towards the game - he is simply wrong and uninformed.
And in regards to the combat feeling insubstantial, he probably played the game on Easy where the enemies don't block. I would like to see him on Hard or Dark where you are almost required to break each and every enemies guard with either a Parry, Riposte, Aard, Quen reflection, Igni, bomb, or trap, all while dodging other foes and making sure you don't give the enemy a chance to counter you.
He begrudges the games for having dwarves and elves. He also mentions the story being "Tolkienified". A few points:
- The Elves in TW are far from anything in LOTR. They are either racially oppressed and enslaved, or living in the woods and hunting down humans who are basically comitting (or would love to commit) genocide against nonhumans.
- Dwarves are shadows of their former selves, living off the bounty of their forebears and getting drunk and fucking all the time. That's their life. They don't mine and are discriminated against just like Elves. NOTHING like LOTR. The only thing they share is their stature and name.
- Saying that these races were "mentioned" in the books is quite stupid. They are integral to the world, and excluding them from the game would be impossible.
It seems to me like he set out with intentions of giving the game a bad review. It's just terrible.
Log in to comment