Hi, I forgot my password on Xbox Live. I called Xbox customer support but since the email I signed the account up with was closed, they won't send the password to my new one. I have tried for years to get this problem resolved but to no avail. Any suggestions?

You're fucked. Try and get the e-mail restored.

It was tied to a company email, once i left the company closed the account.

You definitely should never have linked it to a company e-mail. I'm pretty sure you are out of luck here.

The only option then is to figure out the password. :(

Yep.

That seems odd that they can do literally nothing at this point to help you.  Surely there's a way you can prove that it's your account?

I gave them the last 4 digits of my credit card, my location,  and my real name. They have never once asked my secret question though which kinda grinds my gears. I tell them to send my password to my hotmail account I created awhile back but they just send me the general "Password Troubleshoot" form which gets me nowhere.

That's pretty ridiculous. 


Sue them.