There are a couple of separate issues here which people confuse: content and recruitment. The reason I would prefer someone who's younger and not a white guy is simply one of content. I think it would be best for the product to have a diverse set of voices. Someone younger (or simply young at heart) who can focus the crew on new and exciting products they might otherwise miss is an important aspect. Another is someone who can speak authoritatively from their own experiences with gender and race issues in videogames. Now, there are certainly many issues in the world which a contributor can have experience with: Pat Baer talking about the fansub community is perfect for me! But gender and race issues are topics that come up with some frequency and where every time I feel like they're doing their best, but are lacking somewhat in knowledge and experience. This doesn't mean that they're supposed to comment on the presidential election or the latest police shooting or the dynamics of the BLM movement, it just means that when these issues come up in culture, as they are wont to do, the crew as a whole are better equipped to handle it in QL's and podcasts*.
I take it as a given they'll hire someone who they have good chemistry and banter with, and someone who's driven and produce plenty of content. This is just what I want in addition to that because I think it makes Giant Bomb better.
Recruitment is a different thing all together, and it'd be ludicrous to think that Jeff, et al. are villainous racists/sexists. But we do know that implicit biases exist and recruiting people who aren't white guys (but are just as capable as the ones considered) can be more difficult. So while I agree with the person who said they shouldn't limit their search, I do hope they will make additional efforts to find candidates who are more diverse. And then hire the best person for the job.
*there's a risk that this will lead to whoever it is becoming the default MINORITY CORRESPONDENT, but that's difficult to avoid to some extent; I'd hope it also makes the rest of the guys more willing to go deeper and talk more securely on those matters.
Log in to comment