Nice to hear that these rumours mention a possible return of Paper Mario. It's been a dark time for Nintendo RPGs. Let me break it down:
Mario & Luigi: AlphaDream decided to make 2 different remakes on 3DS instead of making a new game, and subsequently filed for bankruptcy. Their last new game was 2015's Mario & Luigi: Paper Jam, followed by 2017's Mario & Luigi: Superstar Saga + Bowser's Minions (3DS remake of a GBA game), then 2019's Mario & Luigi: Bowser's Inside Story + Bowser Jr.'s Journey (3DS remake of a DS game). Releasing a 3DS game in 2019 was honestly a pretty crazy business move, but I wonder how many 3DS-centric developers had trouble scaling up their development studio to the Switch's specs, so maybe this was the best they could do with the resources they had. Sadly, the series is way too niche to try to do a victory-lap-easy-sales remake. I assume both remakes were probably losses for the studio, given that anecdotally I don't know anyone in person or in games journalism who talked about buying them at all. fwiw, Bowser's Inside Story is quite funny, and the core concept of being inside Bowser and the assorted goofs make it pretty much the pinnacle of the series.
Paper Mario: There hasn't been a truly good Paper Mario since 2004's Paper Mario: The Thousand-Year Door. 2007's Super Paper Mario is a poor gameplay concept that, to their credit, they lavished with as much production value as possible, but it's fundamentally a really dull platformer, though at times the writing and world design still have the flair of TTYD. I have no firsthand account of 2012's Paper Mario: Sticker Star and 2016's Paper Mario: Color Splash, because the combat system looked abysmal and I didn't really care for the way they tried to rebrand the series as papercraft by really playing up the "everything is paper!" angle, and having stickers and real-world objects all over the place.
So I look forward to any kind of improvement on either of these series on the Switch, because it's been pretty rough for quite a few years.
Log in to comment