i loved the way snow falling looking in Donkey Kong Country it always reminds me going up North Ontario where grandparents live
what best looking snow in video games?
Obviously any game that came out this year looks the best but at the time Lost Planet was pretty amazing!
Not the best looking snow, especially if you're taking into account how it reacts to the way the player moves in it, but I really like the look of the snowfall in The Division, as well as a game I'm playing through again which is Mass Effect Andromeda. The snow that flies by you on Voeld looks great. In both games, the way light hits them is impressive to me.
@zombie2011: I quite enjoyed the first Lost Planet at the time. It really stuck with me. Great vibe, and I thought the multiplayer was more then solid.
I feel like RDR2 is the clear winner, but Dead Space 3 was the second game that came to mind.
Many games, even recent ones seem to have issues accurately depicting the way snow reflects light and glimmers, and especially the way a blizzard fucks with your sense of direction, it shouldn't just limit your view distance, snow doesn't tend to fall in a uniform direction, but whirls around in a way that can totally make you lose your orientation if you don't have any visible landmarks around you.
Battlefield V and Battlefront 2 did fairly good jobs at the glimmering part at least, and I'll say that most Quantic Dream games, all other issues aside, have had really good snow for their time, ever since Fahrenheit.
There are technically more impressive games, but when i think snow i think Lost Planet 3.
The original Lost Planet still looks great, and watching your character wade waist deep through snow is still a unique aspect of that game, but LP3 really ramps things up on the art and atmospherics.
I like the gameplay more than most people, but i think we can all agree the art is on point, s*** looks cold.
Without going for the most graphics route, in terms of a fully realised atmosphere and use of light I think SSX3 still holds up really well.
In the same vein, MGS1 is up there too.
There is actually a YouTube video that compares a few game. Steep, Hitman, Uncharted 4, RDR 2, God or War, and Horizon Zero Dawn. I think the RDR2, God of War , and Horizon Zero Dawn video is the most relevant - those three games blow away those others for snow render and deformation.
Shockingly, I think God of War has a noticeable edge over RDR2. The footprints and disruption of snow just turns out more realistic by my eye. God of War's snow just seems to l;ook more like snow whereas RDR2 look like people/animals disrupting a stiff fluid.
While Horizon loses this battle it does do something NEITHER of the other games do. When you want through snow underlying grass appears in your footprint. It is notwell rendered grass or snow, but the snow being a layer with yet another layer beneath is a nice idea.
So the winner, in my mind, is without a doubt God of War.
@zombie2011: Lost Planet captured snow really well. I felt cold playing it.
Wind River was a film that had the same impact on me. Wonderfully captured...
RDR 2 does not merit consideration until they make the game actually have HDR, which yet another patch did not fix.
Rise of the Tomb Raider gets my vote until then. Also, Forza Horizon 4's Winter season looks real good.
I dunno, I've interacted too much with snow in my life to make any of it look good. While the physics of it in games mentioned here is impressive it still doesn't look like real snow to me. I think the problem is that they treat all snow as if it's powder snow, which admittedly makes their tech look great, but it has those same kind of obvious tells that movie snow has.
Edit: Found a picture to illustrate my point.
The right part is what one person going through snow looks like, while videogames tend to look way more like the left side. If you were to walk through snow leaving as much of a trail as you see in videogames you would exhaust yourself in two minutes.
@bmccann42: Yeah, I feel especially great about Wind River as some violin from the score kicked-in early in the film and I thought “holy shit, that’s Warren Ellis!” I looked it up and, sure enough, he did that score with Nick Cave. The guy has a distinctive sound to his violin (play style and equipment) that I absolutely love (check out Nick Cave’s Weeping Song studio recording vs. the life Ellis’ violin brings to it live).
So yeah, I’m way off-topic...great film with beautiful nature shots (including snow) and a wonderful score.
@ares42: New Englander here...not the snowiest place on earth, but we get our share (snowed this afternoon here!).
I’d actually really dig something like a Max Payne remake, or a thriller in a New England town where they just go for it on the snow. Wet snow, heavy snow, icy snow, slick snow, filthy road snow, pristine woods snow, etc. The sound snow brings to an environment, the way it reflects light to blinding degrees...I really want this now...
@bmccann42: It’s on my to-watch list already, but I’ll bump it up. Love westerns as well as the music those men create (Bad Seeds, Dirty Three, Grinderman).
Please Log In to post.
Log in to comment