@ntm: I don't think any intelligent person uses the phrase "valid criticism" to mean absolute, concrete facts to all who have the honor of reading their precious critique. For me, the melee and shooting mechanics are clunky and close to frustrating, especially the PS3 version. I think the PS4 version fixed some of that iffiness just by having a superior controller experience, and it was better, but it's still one of Naughty Dog's least accomplished aspects in their games, that lack of tightness. I'm sure someone will say that's intentional, to emulate the lack of experience these characters had with weapons and combat situations, or that "I had no problems with the shooting or melee", but maybe I'm really unforgiving compared to them? It's valid, because it was true for my experience. Would you say the combat in TLoU is also incredible, or is their room in your reverence to see that it could be considered flawed?
There are stealth sections that are poorly constructed in that game, which is especially apparent on the hardest difficulty setting, and the loose mechanics made it extra frustrating. I picked that difficulty, so I have to take responsibility in that regard, but I think it's the game developers' responsibility to make each difficulty setting cohesive in its own way, but I found the A.I. of the zombies (clickers mostly) in certain sections overly sensitive to the point it felt like an artificially constructed experience on that difficulty. You mentioned another A.I. thing that bugged me, but I wasn't frustrated too much with that stuff.
The setting is perhaps one of the most unoriginal of its kind, and I have no leeway on that point, personally. I'm not saying it wasn't good or enjoyable or well put together, but for me, it was overly familiar and dull at times.
I'm not trying to be inflammatory or unfair with my next comment, but the fact you think it genuinely might be the only game that nobody can have valid criticism toward rubs me the wrong way, not because I don't believe you think it rates that high, but because I think if you can reason and articulate it clearly and well, and aren't too much of a reductive snob, you can criticize everything to some degree, even fairly, as long as you aren't just trying to piss on parades. The Witcher 3 is another prime example of an amazing video game that has its flaws, and The Last of Us is no different, nor is any other game. For me, that is, but I don't think we need to clarify every point with,"in my opinion"s and "for me"s, we know it's all personal at some level.
Log in to comment