I say "tried", because I imagine you'd have to go out of your way to be the shittiest detective possible.  Stepping over corpses/weapons, just looking at the trash, yelling at rape victims, totally believing the "musical talent agent".  Anything hilarious/awful in particular?

I'm so going to do this on a second play through. hahah....

"Ashamed" I legitimately got 1 star on 3 cases.

I've gotten one because I sucked on this one case and it was the one with the rape victim but that's only because I thought selecting "Lie" was wrong because I never get some sweet fanfare music upon selection like I do when I pick "Doubt" or "Truth."

Anyway, I was thinking of playing the clueless cop sometime during my vacation, selecting "Truth" every chance I get. I know I'll get somewhere with that one guy who checked out that one dude's wallet in one of those Traffic cases.

"Ashamed" I legitimately got 1 star on 3 cases.

@CL60 said:

"Ashamed" I legitimately got 1 star on 3 cases.

How? The lowest I have gotten so far is 3.

@Daveyo520 said:

@CL60 said:

"Ashamed" I legitimately got 1 star on 3 cases.

How? The lowest I have gotten so far is 3.

I dunno. I always had all of the clues collected, and no damage, and most of the questions correct. But some of them popped up with 1 star. Golden Butterfly was one of them I think.

I've gotten a 2 star before.  Nothing worse.  :/

I've got two 2s from selecting probably the wrong guy, and a 1 star case in the one with the boxer.  There is only 1 interrogation sequence in it, with three questions.  If you miss a single question you're getting 3 stars, two questions you get 2 ... and I missed all three.

I've got two 2s from selecting probably the wrong guy, and a 1 star case in the one with the boxer.  There is only 1 interrogation sequence in it, with three questions.  If you miss a single question you're getting 3 stars, two questions you get 2 ... and I missed all three.

Got 1 star on Golden Butterfly without trying. 

Got 1 star on the case with the boxer without trying. The Chief really grilled my ass :/

Got 1 star on the case with the boxer without trying. The Chief really grilled my ass :/

I got one yesterday. I missed a couple easy interrogation questions, and I kinda ran over several people with my car. Total accident.

Also got one star on the case with the boxer. Seriously, how are you supposed to read that woman? She's all shifty eyed and shes telling the truth? Yeesh.

I got 1 star on The Golden Butterfly. Completely fucked up the interrogation with the perv, and did a ton of damage behind the wheel too. I think that was the only one, but if you're driving without regard for pedestrians or other cars it becomes a lot easier to 1 star cases.

Yeah i fucked up the first arson case, didn't help Phelp's case but to be honest it wasn't that bad.

I've gotten a 1-star on a couple of cases =/

I got a 1-Star rating on 'The Setup'
I honestly have no idea how I pulled that off, I ended up with most 4-star ratings.

I love shouting at people. Especially the "widow" on one of the earlier cases. *Sob Sob* I'm so worried about my husband detective"  ..."YOUR LYING TO ME YOU PIECE OF TRASH". Not going to be Copper of the year. Would love an option to pull your gun and break a finger with its butt or push a rapist off the roof and claim he fell. Maybe in the sequel.

                    @CL60 said:

@Daveyo520 said:

@CL60 said:

                    "Ashamed" I legitimately got 1 star on 3 cases.

                   

               

How? The lowest I have gotten so far is 3.

                   

               

I dunno. I always had all of the clues collected, and no damage, and most of the questions correct. But some of them popped up with 1 star. Golden Butterfly was one of them I think.

                   

               

That was the case I got three stars on. Seems to be the hardest one to do well on.

                   

               

Got 1 star on Golden Butterfly without trying. 

I have been racking up the four stars, haven't had a single two or three, but I got one star on The Golden Butterfly. I properly effed up on the interogations.

eh, I got 1 star on one of the Vice cases.  Told me to put back on my cop uniform and hit the streets....of course the next case rolls around and I'm still a detective. Kinda disappointed, was hoping I'd have to get back in good graces.

Also got one star on the case with the boxer. Seriously, how are you supposed to read that woman? She's all shifty eyed and shes telling the truth? Yeesh.

I don't even know if I can. Seriously I have weird disliking of intentionally trying to get the worst possible outcome. It's why I've never played through the Suicide Mission in ME2 while making all the worst decisions ever.

Just hit a lot of people if you really want a 1 star rating.

last time i looked at the social club it was something like 8% of people have done 1 star

I got one 1 star case. I really don't think damage or hurting civilians does all that much to impact the case rating. I did a ton of damage on one case and hit a dozen pedestrians and still got 4 stars. I think its more to do with not finding clues and the questions.

It ranks you with stars? I never even noticed. I totally nailed one case, The Golden Butterfly, only to be severely reprimanded by my boss afterwards, and then in the next mission they just boasted about how great I was for solving that last crime. I was like "Wow, you guys are on drugs!"

I received a one star on the Gas Man case, I think. That might actually have been a two star, but I definitely received a one star at some point. I still struggle with the conversations at times, sometimes clues point out that someone is lying and it just does not work, or the suspect words things in a way that doubt and lie could both work, again because I have evidence that should implicate them.  
 
I've finished the game though, so I am very carefully working my way back through old cases with bad scores and attempting to five star everything, if not for the achievement, then just to make myself feel smart in this game for once.

I managed to fuck up a murder case and an arson case so royally that I got a one star. But that was also because I didn't have the evidence to convict the "right" man, both of them being multiple suspects to charge. 

So far the only case I got a one star was that Butterfly one. The only reason though was because (spoilers-ish) I apparently muffed up on the last interrogation or something and it caused a chase sequence, causing the culprit to crash into a trolley and causing lots of money in damage (my partner even shot out one of his tires and almost got the other one. FML) 
 
Otherwise, I get 3 or more stars.

I got a 1 star on one of the cases that i chose the wrong guy

I've got 1 star once so far and I'll probably fix that during the second play-through. 

@CL60 said:

@Daveyo520 said:

@CL60 said:

"Ashamed" I legitimately got 1 star on 3 cases.

How? The lowest I have gotten so far is 3.

I dunno. I always had all of the clues collected, and no damage, and most of the questions correct. But some of them popped up with 1 star. Golden Butterfly was one of them I think.

That was the case I got three stars on. Seems to be the hardest one to do well on.

I messed up that one boxing case BIG TIME.

Going against the captains wishes in Golden Butterfly will really give your score a massive hit at the end.

Did on the boxer case. Screwed up royally with the questions, of which there are only three. 
 
Did anyone else feel that case was almost surreal in its conclusion? Randomly finding the boxer and the assailant in an abandoned cinema complex, where there's some mad monologuing going on? Not to mention the plot jumps from point-to-point so quickly - it has to be one of the shortest in the game. I was half-expecting Cole to wake up in his office and have it be that the case was all a dream of his.

I got one star on the first arson case. At some point, I just lost the story thread and got all confused.

"Ashamed" I legitimately got 1 star on 3 cases.

I got 1 star on the Golden Butterfly case. Everything was going relatively well until I completely screwed up both interrogations at the end.

@Daveyo520 said:

@CL60 said:

"Ashamed" I legitimately got 1 star on 3 cases.

How? The lowest I have gotten so far is 3.

I dunno. I always had all of the clues collected, and no damage, and most of the questions correct. But some of them popped up with 1 star. Golden Butterfly was one of them I think.

This reminded me of an idea I had to play through the game as Truth Cop, the cop who is just too nice of a guy and pretty much believes everyone.
 
He's so naive.