@acharlie1377: When you start arguing personality you are going beyond objectification, but are delving into more meaningful versions of sexism, which are just as present in Western games which is exactly my point. I agree with those aspects as you bring them up. If you refer to my first post in this thread (on page 2) I bring up that there are sexist elements to the game, but those same elements, behavioral elements, are just as present in Western games and media so pretending its just a JRPG thing is silly. However, your entire argument up until now has been that the only value of women in XBC2 is their appearance, which is not true.
Sexualizing characters is not problematic because it doesn't say anything on its own. All it says is you are uncomfortable with female sexuality and the female body. This is only viewed as harmful to you because you feel uncomfortable by it, which is part of the problem. It is one of the things that comes up with real world rape a lot that women who wear revealing clothes (or any clothes that somebody finds attractive) is "asking for it" which is just as much telling women to be afraid of, or ashamed, of their own sexuality and body. That is why it is problematic to condemn something for having scantily clad characters, because it goes the other direction of oppressing women. Objectification is not a myth in the same way male gaze is, but Pyra, Mythra, or any female character in the game does not exhibit this because they play vital roles to the story. If you were to remove any female character the story would be lessened and would change dramatically. In this regard you are misusing the term objectification, that is to say that the only value that these women play in the game is as scene dressing.
Also the article I linked was in regard to male gaze not the rest of it. I pointed that out when I linked it. The point of male gaze as a concept delegitimize points of view on sexuality that are not hetero in nature by assuming that only men find it pleasing or that all men find it pleasing, which is not the case in any sense. It is a very heteronormative way to view the world that is provably false. However, Bayonetta does engage in feminine behavior as you described. I mean, the opening scene of Bayonetta 2 is her shopping.
Log in to comment