The collective "UHHHH" as the guys rounded the corner in The Dark Room made me laugh a lot, your guys' reactions are great. The playdate eps motivated me to actually go out and play LiS, and now that I know what happens I'm doubly excited to see you guys play episode 5.
I had a feeling you would use that exact screenshot if Undertale wound up on your list. It's a good list.
Pulseline's comments