Giant Bomb's Mathematically Accurate Game of the Year
I thought it would be fun to see how closely an average of the guy's personal game of the year lists would match up with the site's list as a whole. I took Alex, Brad, Drew, Jeff, Patrick and Vinny's personal lists and assigned each game a score based on its position: The game at number 10 gets 1 point, the game at number 1 gets 10 points.
Someone else has probably gone ahead and done this before me, but I wanted to do it myself anyway.
Last of Us a clear winner, with a pretty huge twelve point difference between it and Gone Home; the rest of the top 5 all pretty close and then another pretty big drop, of 8 points to Saints Row IV and the bottom five.
