Something went wrong. Try again later

Giant Bomb News

164 Comments

Worth Reading: 11/09/12

This week, we've got a controversial take on Halo 4, a web browser game that doesn't suck, a fan who's trying to remake Aliens vs. Predator, and your usual assortment of links to fill the weekend.

No Caption Provided

If all goes according to plan, I’ll pull the trigger on ordering parts for my computer over the weekend, and finally put into motion an idea I’ve been kicking around for a couple of years now. It’s been so, so long since I’ve built a PC, though, so I’ve forgotten...everything. I’ve heard your requests, too, and we’ll probably film putting it together and bringing it to life. Nothing can go wrong with that, right?

As mentioned in the last episode of Spookin’ With Scoops, where we played the first hour or so of System Shock 2, that feature will take a rest until the PC comes together, which means it probably won’t come back until after Thanksgiving. Even with a powerful PC, that doesn’t mean we’ll leave behind a return to Lone Survivor, System Shock 2, or even Friday the 13th and Clock Tower for SNES. It will, however, mean closing out episodes with Slender won’t look like a total trainwreck.

A few weeks away from horror will do my heart some good, too. You can only take so much.

Hey, You Should Play This

No Caption Provided

It’s early days for browser games, but Save the Day, a fast-paced action game in which players fly a helicopter and save people from imminent disaster, make a solid case for what’s possible when competent developers are in the drivers seat. It doesn’t have to be all exploitative free-to-play games that are more about wasting time than they are about learning and enjoying game mechanics. Let’s also remember Supergiant Games managed to port Bastion to Chrome’s app store on HTML5. It’ll be some time before we’re seeing a game like Bastion made from the ground up for a browser, but the potential audience is enormous, and it’s only a matter of time before someone makes a killing.

There are also two other games I’m going to link to below, and I’ll say nothing more about them.

And You Should Read These, Too

No Caption Provided

What do you want from your reviews? Do you want someone to reaffirm your preconceived notions about a game, or do you want to be challenged, and look at a game in a new light? Tom Chick’s review of Halo 4 would probably do a better job of accomplishing the latter if a score wasn’t attached, but the score is what made his review a lightning rod. Chick is used to being the industry’s punching bag, and publishing contradictory opinions is nothing new. I haven’t yet played Halo 4, so I can’t say whether or not I agree with his conclusions about the latest entry, but it’s a well articulated argument, and definitely an outlier from the general consensus. Does that make it wrong? (Hint: no.)

This is Halo 4. A shiny old dog without any new tricks. I got more out of the Halo 1 remake, which at least had the appeal of nostalgia. Playing through an updated version of the original Halo was at times tired or tedious. But it was also a reminder of the raw genius that launched the series. There is none of that in Halo 4, which is a drawn-out retread without any fresh perspective or energy, and furthermore missing a lot of what I need to pull me through a Halo game. Halo 4 demonstrates that if there’s one thing worse than more of the same, it’s less of the same.
No Caption Provided

Games have trouble keeping secrets these days, and whatever you think of Assassin’s Creed III, it’s admirable the company was able to keep a lid on a particularly cool twist that comes early in the game. If you haven’t played Assassin’s Creed III, you should not click this link, but if you have, Ars Technica has talked to Ubisoft about the process of keeping a secret over a three-year development cycle and huge amounts of marketing. Not easy!

May says he didn't even discuss the big reveal with his closest friends or family—he just "couldn't take the risk." While he could talk about [CENSORED] with other members of the development team, that didn't really relieve the stress. "All we would end up doing was riling ourselves up. We were on thisthing, and we were all having the same fears and anxious nervous anticipation. That didn't make it any easier."

If You Click It, It Will Play

I Don’t Know About This Kickstarter Thing, But These Projects Seem Pretty Cool

  • Elite is the latest classic trying to come back. Would be nice if they showed, uh, anything about it.
  • We need more physical spaces to show off video games. L.A. Game Space could be terrific.
  • Wait, is Distance a spiritual successor to San Francisco Rush?

The Latest Assassin's Creed is Out, And There Are Mixed Opinions

Valve Just Launched Greenlight, So Here’s Some Games That Don’t Look Terrible

  • Dark Rain looks awfully early, but an open world horror game with a day/night cycle? Yes.
  • Draw a Stickman has players getting involved by actually drawing objects into the world.
  • Sapience is a modern attempt to create a DOOM-style sci-fi RPG. Those are golden words.

Oh, And This Other Stuff

Patrick Klepek on Google+

164 Comments

Avatar image for deactivated-6610658acf7f5
deactivated-6610658acf7f5

962

Forum Posts

23877

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

Hey, a Tom Chick shout out! Cool. I recommend people read the review and also his linked FAQ.

As for the whole reviews as artistic criticism or as product evaluations, I hope to see reviewers trend towards the former. I'll leave it at that.

Avatar image for jasondesante
jasondesante

615

Forum Posts

2

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 6

User Lists: 0

Edited By jasondesante

I'm also gonna make a PC soon, these are my goals

2nd monitor with the big screen, adapters for retro consoles, all the emulators in the world plus all the roms/iso's in the world

I hate media streaming...might as well hook up the pc straight to the tv and run everything at the highest resolution possible :D

It's easier to play San Andreas on PC with a PS2 emulator than it is to use the actual PC version on Steam!

Looking forward to building this setup then adding an Ouya when it comes out!

Avatar image for 2kings
2kings

167

Forum Posts

1

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

Edited By 2kings

I want to posit one more idea I have about "opinions". Especially as they refer to "reviews".

I hear the words "it's their opinion, it can't be wrong" a lot. While this may be true to some degree I don't think it applies to reviews in the same way. I think they aren't JUST opinions, they're opinions guided by wisdom and experience. Anyone can just put their opinions out there, but it takes a much more even hand to appraise a product, which interactive entertainment straddles a VERY thin line between art and product. Even so, simple things as factual errors (that mini-mac totally shoots the bajesus out of shit) should not/could not happen if you are being paid for your expertise and take it very seriously.

If you're going to attach a score you have passed a threshold into entirely different territory. Have some respect for your readers.

Avatar image for conwako
conwako

2

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

Edited By conwako

To be honest I don't see where the surprise comes from. If you look at Metacritic, Qt3 is one of the harshest critics tracked there, Their average score is 11 points below the overall average (note: Edge Magazine is 10 points lower).

Personally I enjoyed both the game and the review.

Avatar image for sunjammer
Sunjammer

1177

Forum Posts

408

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 17

User Lists: 7

Edited By Sunjammer

"Early days for browser games"?

Avatar image for tpoppapuff
TPoppaPuff

522

Forum Posts

6

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 5

User Lists: 1

Edited By TPoppaPuff

So basically Tom Chick is trolling for hits to his page. Yeah, that sounds about right. He's acting like a typical cynical dissenter; someone who argues for the sake of arguing. He believes being "counterculture" makes him "valuable," "progressive" and (most hilariously misguided of all) "unique." Truth is his complaints are hardly valid. Yes, Halo 4 still has you moving the player across the map and shooting enemies in the head; guilty as charged. It's damning because no matter what this game did, this hater was gonna hate because that's what haters do. It's the most original Halo title since the original with the exception of Halo Wars, which doesn't count (I'm not going to count an unrelated RTS that slaps a name on the box and adds some repurposed CG-cutscenes.). To complain about some of the repetition in the title itself is a valid complaint (does it always have to be three of something?), but his complaint of not completely revolutionizing the entire shooter genre is an absurd complaint. He should be treated just like any other troll; just report him, ignore him and move on.

Avatar image for hippie_genocide
hippie_genocide

2574

Forum Posts

1

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 2

Edited By hippie_genocide

I think Tom Chick actually believes the shit he writes, and doesn't just do it to be contrarian or to get clicks. If you just read the text of the review, his complaints have merit. Which is why scoring is dumb. Its not a 1/5 game, its just not. Superman 64 and MK: Advance are 1/5 type games. No other medium feels compelled to attach number values to their reviews, so I wish games would follow suit. Is it the perception that gamers have small attention spans or what?

Avatar image for zfubarz
zFUBARz

719

Forum Posts

178

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 1

Edited By zFUBARz

You know that Assassin's creed video is cool and all but I still don't understand why people think that free running has to be crazy flips and shit. the whole point of Parkour was to move efficiently and smoothly across the environment in as straight of a line as possible, doing a kick flip off a tree and somersaults over logs is not that. and frankly makes that whole video longer than it should be and a lot less intense.

Avatar image for raptorsrevenge
raptorsrevenge

25

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

Edited By raptorsrevenge

Not sure if I agree with the Halo score, but I agree with the criticism. Nothing that spectacular behind those beautiful visuals. The COD esque ending was a little appalling, we can all agree on that, right?

Avatar image for smokachino
Smokachino

3

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

Edited By Smokachino

Wow. That Halo 4 review is worthless. Is that what qualifies as professional these days? Yes, Halo 4 missed the mark on some things, but to only focus on the bad and ignore the mountain of things it did right is just a sloppy attempt at being a contrarian.

Avatar image for smokachino
Smokachino

3

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

Edited By Smokachino

@theanticitizen: Completely agree.

Avatar image for arker101
Arker101

1484

Forum Posts

1

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 1

Edited By Arker101

I agree that 343 didn't measure up in the end. I think his review is correct, but unfortunately he writes it in a way that comes of as arrogant. From the multiplayer to the campaign, everything was sub-par compared to the earlier entries in the series. Heck even the iconic "Monk-Chants" in the main menu are awful compared to Halo 3.

I understand that 343 couldn't go all the way and make it their franchise with their own ideas and innovations, but what parts of it resemble the old Halo are disappointing.

Avatar image for mrwug
mrwug

12

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

Edited By mrwug

I'm thoroughly annoyed they posted a link to that Halo 4 review. I respect Giant Bomb's opinions, and then they link to that troll review done exclusively for the notoriety on Metacritic. Halo 4 is a very well made, highly polished game. It might not be your thing, but the idea that "it sucks" is absurd. It's like saying Casablanca sucks. It's a stance that is indicative of motives other than a fair review, and in this case those motives are generating web traffic by being the only reviewer on Metacritic to lambast a good game.

Avatar image for honkyjesus
honkyjesus

140

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 3

User Lists: 0

Edited By honkyjesus

@mrwug: It is his opinion.

That is like saying your opinion that the game is good is wrong.