Community GOTY voting issues go here!

I'm going to throw up the Community GOTY voting sometime...soon!™ If you notice any issues voting on games please let us know here and we'll get it sorted.

Howdy. Oxygen Not Included listed as a 2017 game but actually just came out of early access in July of this year. I imagine that's gotta be pretty common for early access games. Cool list! First time voting here :D

I can vote for FFXIV: Shadowbringers (my no. 2) but not Destiny 2: Shadowkeep (my no. 1). Unfortunately I'm not going to vote if I can't vote for my number 1 game of the year.

I'd like to include 10 Beautiful Postcards by thecatamites in my top ten but, understandably for a small game, it's not on the list. Any chance it could be added? Thanks for running this btw.

Judgment comes up as a 2018 release in the list due to the Japanese release, but it didn't come out in the US until 2019, so it should count, right?

I would include Wow: Classic on my list but not sure if that should just be a vote for World of Warcraft 2004?

Judgment is only listed as a 2018 game. I understand this is due to it being originally released on Dec 13th of 2018 in Japan, but other territories did not see it released until June 25th of 2019.

Not as much a bug as an observation: I would absolutely love functionality of reorganizing the list items by drag-and-drop, a la Steam Wishlist. It would be reeeeaaallly helpful to be able to type all of my votes out and then organize them.

I'd also like to know this Matt

Monster Hunter World: Iceborne doesn't seem to be popping up either..

[edit] or is this considered DLC for Monster Hunter World and should I then list Monster Hunter World as my item?

This may already be accounted for, but Slay the Spire was an early access game.

Official release was this year and the database says 2017. Thank for all you do, rorie!

I too second or I guess third the WoW Classic question.

another down for WoW Classic option

@tinysouffle: @sombre: @oddjob86: @shamanick: @lawl3rbawl3r: I don't believe we generally make separate pages for re-issues or remakes of older games unless they are substantially different than the previous versions. If you vote for the base World of Warcraft game from 2004 we'll count that as WoW classic. Or any WoW votes really since there wasn't an expansion this year.

@pizzadivine:

It looks like this is on the Wiki now:

https://www.giantbomb.com/10-beautiful-postcards/3030-76379/

Trying to put in Destiny 2: Shadowkeep. I know it is an expansion but doesn't it count? Not showing up as an option.

I'd also like to know about how I should vote for Monster Hunter World: Iceborne. Can't get it to pop up, as it's just considered a DLC in the system, but it was also a separate release. Will voting for the 2018 base game count, or will it just get filtered out?

Hi! I'm not able to find Pic-a-Pix: Pieces by Lightwood Games (released Jan 2 this year). Any chance this could be added? Thanks!

Yes, it's not a separate game. Just enter it as MHW.

The beauty of the wiki is that anyone can add a game. I've done it for you though.

Pic-a-Pix Pieces

It's not a separate game. Just enter it as Destiny 2.

Yes.

MMOs uniquely carry a heritage of expansion packs dating back to the days before DLC or "ongoing games" were a concept, which is why they still get separate pages in our system. For games like Destiny, Monster Hunter, etc., they are listed as DLC.

So, you can enter Shadowbringers on your list and you can add Destiny 2 to your list. They will both count towards the overall tally.

You can still add it and it will count.

@marino: Thank you very much! My apologies, I wasn't aware of this.

I was actually going to ask where it was that I cast my votes in for the community GOTY, because I legit couldn't find it in any obvious spot on the site. I had no idea when or where it was going up. But I dug into the Community Highlights and found it there. Here's the link if anyone needs it.

@marino: can i vote for card game for their expansions this year that ive enjoyed and have it count? even though those games themselves are years old

@sorla10: Not sure if you're talking about a physical card game or a game that we would actually list in the wiki.