this is something that i hate about myself..

whenever i play a game and i see something cool happen but then i realize it could've happened cooler and i start imagining different scenarios in the game and i kind of remove myself from the game which i hate. do you ever do weird stuff like that where you image a better game?

no?

you might make a good game developer. if a brutal one. 
 
at the very least an elitist critic.

You sound like my English teacher. In class today he was trying to improve on one of Shakespeare's sonnets. Not to say Shakespeare is perfect, but somehow this lowly eleventh grade English teacher trying to make revisions to Sonnet 55 seemed silly. 
 
Anyways no, I don't think I do that. If I really like a game I might think about alternate ways it could have played out, but rarely have I thought; "I would have done that better." Well, save for awful, awful story choices. 

I do that with movies/ TV shows (Heroes for example) more than anything. You could say the consumer knows best

Sometimes.  I think of crazy shit that could have happen in Super Mario Galaxy or Bayonetta, but I still enjoyed the games for what they are.

Playing Bad Dudes will remedy your problem.

Yes, a lot when I feel limited by the mechanics of some games.

Cool story, bro.

I do that with sub-par video games, but only because I think "how could you have missed this!?"

Yeah I feel the same too. 
Dante's Inferno is an example of a game I could have directed to be much better.

I so could have made this thread better.

" you might make a good game developer. if a brutal one.  at the very least an elitist critic. "

I something think something like this, but only on reflection, not while i am playing.
 
It usually involves realisitic violence though.

I hate my laziness :)

No, the only time I'll really start imagining how something could have happened better is if it's glaringly poorly done,

i always feel as if im playing the game wrong, i always think im missing stuff, this leads to me playing like a retard and actually missing key scenes.