I absolutely loved The Witcher 1 - I played it in 2011, just before Skyrim came out, so I didn't try to really get into Witcher 2 until much later. I dunno why, but I felt like TW2 didn't pull me into its world like TW1 did, and they made some fundamental changes that I wasn't thrilled with. They very much changed the style of game in some key ways; TW1 has multiple camera views, including a top-down style view that makes it look and feel a bit more like Diablo - TW1 is powered by the Aurora Engine, which was made by BioWare as the successor to the Infinity Engine, and which powered both Neverwinter Nights games. I found myself using this top-down view a lot; it especially made it easier to navigate around the world (just click one button and wait rather than directly controlling his every move) and it was useful to see more of the battlefield when taking on larger groups of enemies. TW2 is strictly a third-person game, and feels much more like they tried to make it more action oriented, maybe not so much in the core mechanics, but definitely in the presentation of said mechanics. Let me put it this way: they put out a console version of TW2, and it felt perfectly natural that they did - putting out a console version of TW1 would have been weird.
A loose analogy would be to say that The Witcher 1 is Dragon Age: Origins to The Witcher 2's Mass Effect - specifically ME2. A lot of people like ME more than DA:O, and a lot of people like TW2 more than TW1, but I know which side I'm on, and am totally fine with that. I'm also crazy enough to think that Mass Effect 1 is the best ME game. So in saying which one to play...well obviously I haven't played through TW2 so my words only carry so much weight. But the bigger problem is that I can only really speak for myself, and I know that my opinion doesn't necessarily represent what could be seen as the "status quo".
If you have the time and the means to play both games, you absolutely should - not just the OP, everyone should give them a try. As you'd expect from a game that's got a strong foundation in proper fantasy literature, the world is unique, vivid, and endlessly entertaining to explore. But TW1's mechanics might not resonate with you as much as they did with me, and if that discouraged you from playing TW2 then that would be a bummer. Also, TW1 is visually functional, whereas TW2 is straight up gorgeous. That might not matter to you; it matters to some people.
And regarding the difficulty, it always felt to me like The Witcher 2 expected you to understand its systems and its mechanics because it assumed you'd played The Witcher 1, but they completely changed a lot of those systems and mechanically so thoroughly that they were almost unrecognisable. It's like saying that you know how to play The Settlers of Catan because you've read the rulebook for Monopoly.
Log in to comment