@tireyo643:
Professionals are human. There is always a chance they can screw up. That's why you always have the option of going to a different one. But your average person has almost zero chance of diagnosing anything, and a 0% chance when you remove blind luck.
My mother was diagnosed with schizophrenia and clinical depression right after I was born. I lived with her for 20 years. Due to those 20 years, I can tell you exactly when she is about to slip into an episode, either in person or over the phone, and despite having moved out for a number of years. I know it just from the inflection in her voice, or by her mannerisms at that time. To me, it is as plain as day and no amount of time apart will rob me of that ability, such were my formative years with her.
However:
I have never, and will never, attempt to operate outside of the advise and instruction of her doctors. The most I have ever done is suggest to my father that a second opinion might be warranted if her medication and therapy do not seem to be helping her manage this chemical imbalance. That's all. To do any more is folly; at best, I can accidentally replicate the positive influence that therapy has provided her. At worst, I can kill her. Plain and simple.
I don't mean to seem that I am cold or indifferent to her situation. I have spent countless hours sitting down with her, helping her work through each episode with as much care and love as I can muster. My father and I have lost many nights of sleep in our attempts to, for lack of a better phrase, help her make it through the night. It truly is hearbreaking to see old video tapes of (to put it bluntly) the mother that I never knew, with this effervescent and outgoing personality. The effect on my father is profound, and I now worry about him as well.
But no amount of personal experience, no amount of self-research, and no amount of care will ever allow me to make accurate medical calls, and that goes ten times as much for people that I have never met. I had a friend that, in his desire to do good, accidentally put his girlfriend into a coma. He, after days upon days of "research", had decided that her dosage was incorrect. He was put on trial for that negligence; he maintained (and I imagine still maintains) he had nothing but the best interests of the girl in mind. He planned to marry her; had the ring and everything. It didn't matter; what he did was wrong, and he's paying for that. Luckily, she recovered. If not, the punishment (and the tragedy) would have been far greater.
Professionals can fail. They have failed in the past. But your average person, regardless of how similar their situation may be, should offer no more advice to another beyond "seek professional guidance" as your average person is so much more likely to do harm then good. Even if we leave the medication side out of it, the most a person can do is poorly emulate a therapist.
Once proper medical advice has been sought, you can lend as much support and care to another as possible. But you cannot use that as a substitute, and medical help should be the first thing you suggest. There is no obligation to accept the advice of a professional, after all. No need to try anti-depressants or engage in some sort of therapy even if you are suggested to do so. But you will not know if this is required until you go, and that's why I hesitate to offer any suggestion to a stranger beyond "Seek professional help."
Log in to comment