think the idea is explosive but its gonna fail for two reasons : the public isnt ready for such a huge achievement of a game, AND i think the intentions of the MAG people are good but they're gonna fail at delivering the awesomness they intend to deliver.. 

although I am very much interested in this game I must say that both predictions are what they are, Predictions. Lets just wait until the game is out then make a sound judgment. Whether its going to outshine or doomed fro failure is for time to tell.  
 
P.S - This thread should be on the MAG Forums.

And then there's people like me who are in the beta but can't discuss it.

" And then there's people like me who are in the beta but can't discuss it. "

I think that the sense that its a big battlefield needs to be conveyed at some point in every match otherwise i could play killzone or whatever and get the same experience. 
 
Can we fly helicopters and jets in it? i thought the paradrop thing looked very computer controlled 

I think it will be a great game but only if it can organize the combat well. I have pretty high hopes for it though.

7 day's until the open Beta so you can find out for your self.......
And then we can discuss this based on fact's...

32 player matches are disorganized enough. Finding 256 competent players will be impossible. Everyone is just going to try and be rambo and the whole concept will fall apart. I think the game can be made, and I'm hoping its great. I don't have faith in the community though.

" @Diamond: Obviously of course you woudn't be able to say things like that why would they want the cummunity to hear positive feedback from testers. ; ) "

i think that the game is going to have things that were promised but aren't there. it's just something that i think will happen when mag comes out.

" @iam3green: Well how is the game going to have them if they aren't there? lol "

It's going to be a well reviewed game that I'm going to hate.  
 
(usually the way shooters work me, i.e. I don't like Call of Duty...)

I played it a PAX and I enjoyed it, but it was exactly what you'd expect, a B grade shooter with a big player number.