@evilcalvin: Except he didn't give it 4/10, he gave it 2/5.
Which equates to a 4/10 on a 10 point scale. Since Metacritic and GameRankings use a 100 point scale you need to convert that to the 10/100 point scale to compare. 2/5= 4/10 which equates to 40%. Basic math grasshopper!
2/5 in no way equates to a 4/10 on a 10 point scale. Jeff has said this numerous times over the years, grasshopper.
Giant Bomb review scale:
5/5 - This game is awesome, everyone should play
4/5 - Pretty great, some key flaws, fans of genre/similar games will enjoy
ADAMWD's comments