The writing was on the wall for AV when Gia Manry and John Martone were kicked out, essentially leaving the site in a state of leaderless anarchy. Still, I'm surprised it lasted as long as it did. Tom Pinchuk put up lots of video content (and will continue to do so, from what I hear), @takashichea did the thankless work of keeping the wiki up and the community together with a few other mods, I even managed to keep a semi-monthly community podcast going for just over a year before I got bored and handed the reins to my co-hosts (look up the "Bravo Whiskey podcast," they did a better job archiving that one than I did for its originator). On a smaller note, it also convinced me to finally sign up for Giant Bomb and I made a few more "internet friends."
Having said that, a common refrain I heard from third parties (especially after Gia and John were gone) was that AV wasn't quite sure what it wanted to be: A wikipedia for anime/manga? There were already plenty of sites for that. Maybe it could've worked as a detailed episode guide site but there were too few people willing to cover that angle for nothing more than fake internet points, especially with regards to less-popular anime. A place to discuss anime/manga? Unless you were there to roleplay/battle there wasn't much discussion going on in the forums. As for user/community reviews, MyAnimeList has that stuff on lock (for better or worse). An anime/cosplay photo gallery? That led to some serious disdain from GB as well as getting the site blacklisted on several internet filters after several users abused it for...darker ends. At least until our former backend wizard Ethan stepped in (then when he left, the creepers came back).
Tom, bless his heart, tried to keep up the video host/personality side of things on the site after it was used as a dumping ground for GB interns who were literally copy-pasting Funimation video ads on the site as "content." Even so, the videos were/are pretty lo-fi compared to the previous taped stuff, let alone what GB has now, and they're lucky if the youtube hits ever break into the thousands. Maybe it'll change now that he's become the self-appointed Shogun of what remains of AV, but I don't know.
Wow, that was a lot of words. In short, AV was another cool idea that got knocked off course really early and never quite found its way back, especially after the Whiskey Media split.
Log in to comment