GOTY 2014
This year I was in full PC-only territory, which also meant I played barely any games that CAME OUT THIS YEAR. But it was still a great year of GAMES THAT I PLAYED.
I finally got around to Far Cry 3, which was very, very good and not nearly as much of a mess story-wise as I thought it would be. Nicely told, but the obvious mistake of Vaas not being the ultimate foe really did stand out, but luckily I knew that going in so I wasn't too shaken. The kind of game you just don't want to end.
I also completed Batman: Arkham Origins, which was also very, very good. The Arkham games have, to my great surprise, become contenders for my favorite Batman material; comics, movies and TV included. I think Origins WAS important to have, even if it is pretty much one long flash-back in the franchise. The dimension given to Bane and the Joker worked very well, and this game might have my favorite Batsuit design of all time.
Saints Row: The Third, is the little open-world game that could. You can almost sense a sort of "we'll probably never make another one of these so throw it all in" mentality throughout, even the casual way "major" character fates are handled. They take off all the restraints of gameplay-balancing concerns and it makes for a wild, eventually super-easy, and always fun game. But in retrospect, the idea that the guys at Giant Bomb almost gave this GOTY 2011 over Skyrim is utterly ridiculous. It's good but... I mean seriously... It's been three years and I STILL play Skyrim now and then.