Finished it last night, and have to agree the endings are pretty unsatisfying. Aside from the obvious nihilistic downer, I think (for me at least) its because I see what they went for and how badly they fucked it up.
The 'twist' (resist) ending is supposed be a big reveal that you have fulfilled the biblical prophecy of Revelation, that god actually does talk to Joseph, and that the world is ending. That could potentially be a good twist, except for:
- They made the nuclear Armageddon too ambiguous. You had to have listened to the radio news broadcasts to pick up on the foreshadowing. With the radio being optional, a lot of players missed it and couldn't tell if it was war, or the Seeds setting off nukes.
- They cherry picked a bunch of stuff from Revelation and inserted it into the game way too subtly. If they had called more attention to them (e.g. Sherrif Whitehorse is the "White Horse" who comes from the heavens, and behind him is one who "in righteousness he judges and makes war") then maybe the ending would have more impact on the player. But as it is the twist is more like an easter egg since the clues are all hidden and obscure.
- Most players will not have a passing knowledge of the book of revelations, so you need to expose them to that stuff before springing it on them in the end. It would be like (Usual Suspects spoiler ahead) revealing that Verbal Kint is Keyser Soze, without explaining at all who Kaiser Soze is beforehand.
- The obvious fact that the ending doesn't fit with the tone of the rest of the game.
So, yeah, the actual ending is that Joseph was really a prophet, and you're the "pale rider" or "death" or "lamb of god" or whatever who comes from heaven with the White Horse, opens the seals, and causes judgement day - which is heralded by "trumpets" (air raid sirens). Joseph is chosen by god, he can't be killed, and everything you did was foretold, unavoidable, etc. The twist isn't really the nuclear war, it's that the war is the culmination of the prophecy of Revelations (so, god is real, joseph was right, and you are turbo-fucked), and since they don't make that clear enough it just feels like a random gut punch, rather than a profound twist.
Whats interesting to me is they are sort of ripping off Kevin Smith's Red State. Bunch of religious cultists, outnumbered law enforcement, teen murder - and in Smith's original ending (that they couldn't afford to film) the movie ends with the biblical Armageddon signaled by heavenly trumpets and the world ending.
Log in to comment