@slag: @supermike6: No, nobody is derailing anything. I'm so giddy right now because this is exactly what I wanted from this blog... I wanted discussion and positivity and I'm getting both of those things from you guys. You aren't arguing you are discussing a topic and I love it. By all means keep going but I'm going to throw my opinion in now...
Man those are three pretty weighty games to tackle in one week. You didn't beat them all this week did you? because if you did , holy cow is that impressive.
I wish I could have beaten all three but I only completed Majora's Mask last week, I had beaten both of the others when they released and wanted to jump back in to see how they hold up, both of them surprised me because they are totally playable and enjoyable still today.
Anyway, I think there is an obvious aesthetic difference between JRPG's and WRPG's and as someone who played a ton of RPG's on the SNES and PS1 when I jumped into something like Daggerfall I thought I was playing a completely new game, I wasn't even sure it was an RPG. I was uninformed at the time and it wasn't until years later when I learned that there were RPG's from the west and the east.
I think we still use that distinction because while there are tons of similarities as @slag mentioned you can see the differences in everything from the box art to the color palette used within. It is more of a visual difference on the outside but when you start playing a game in either you immediately see that they're extremely similar in design, whether it be communicating with NPC's or undertaking quests. So while I will admit that we may not even need this classification anymore I am an old man, haha... and have now been referring to them in this way for 20 years now so get off my lawn. Keep this discussion going if you guys like though... you two said everything perfectly so there wasn't much left for me to add.
Also, @supermike6 you discussed the music in a JRPG and I could not agree with you more. When I play a classic on my VITA now I put in headphones (not just to drown out my daughter) but so I can hear the music. I love how they use it to convey every single emotion, ie. the sheer terror when you see an entire village burning to the ground while Sephiroth stands in the center of it all. I love video game music but I would say that 15 of my 20 favorite tracks are from JRPG's.
Log in to comment