Gundam Series Reviews Part 1
By joshth 14 Comments
After all the talk between Austin and Vinny about Gundams, I decided it was time to dive head first into this fandom and watch basically every single Gundam related product that I could. I was curious how someone today would feel about the franchise and its various entries coming in completely cold. After researching a bit how to go about doing this, I decided that I would work my way through the series based on when it was released, starting with the earliest. This way I wouldn't have to worry about not picking up on references to past entries, which it seems like this franchise quite enjoys doing. Up till this point I have made it through Gundam 0080 War in the Pocket. I have skipped Gundam ZZ because it was hard for me to actually find a way to watch it, and because it is supposedly very bad. Anyways on with my thoughts on the first few franchise entries!
WARNING: SPOILERS FOR THESE GUNDAM SERIES WILL BE ABUNDANT
Mobile Suit Gundam 0079: 5/10 gundams
The series that started it all. I found it interesting to learn that this show initially did horrible ratings wise, leading to it being cancelled part way through and ending up with less episodes then the creators had expected. Here we follow Amuro, a sort of bratty child as he gets shoved into participating in The One Year War against the wonderfully German Principality of Zeon. He's joined by a cute but kind of obnoxious spherical robot, a nagging female friend Fraw Bow who claims to care about Amuro yet consistently questions his manhood when he is unwilling to continue being a CHILD SOLIDER, The 'new to leadership' Captain Bright who really enjoys hitting people, and a myriad of other crew members that make up the White Base. These characters are all decently interesting and most get at least a couple of episodes to really flesh themselves out.
But the real stars of the show are actually the villains. Characters like Ramba Ral, all of the Zabi clan except for Gihren, and obviously Char Aznable himself all seem to be far more complex characters, and help to make the show more than your standard Saturday morning cartoon(anime). There were times I really was rooting for Zeon, simply because they had the more interesting and more fleshed out characters.
But now, why did I give the series that started that sweet Gundam magic such a middling score? Well for starters this series definitely suffers with age. The animation is quite poor, and battle scenes are sometimes legitimately hard to even follow what's going on because of this. The music was OK at setting mood, but often repetitive and nothing that stood out as really helping to get out the emotions of the characters. This series also suffers from horrible pacing issues. Things start out well enough, with just enough time for it be believable how these civilians got caught up in the war without making things too slow/boring. But then there are like literally twenty episodes before anything resembling a "main plot" really starts moving again. You have some interesting stuff with Char and Garma but that's pretty much it. The ending has the opposite problem, likely a result of the series having to end before being ready, leading to important characters like Lalah feeling like she barely had an impact.
I also had some serious problems with the whole AMURO YOU NEED TO MAN UP AND FIGHT LIKE A GOOD CHILD SOLIDER, this didn't seem like it was played to make us think about how this was a complete tragedy, instead it was played as this is what a good citizen (and man) does is rises to the occasion. That might just be a "it's nearly forty years since then and our views as a society on this issue may have changed" thing though.
Mobile Suit Zeta Gundam: 6/10 Gundams and 10/10 Quattro Bajeenas
Here we move from a sometimes obnoxious protagonist to an extremely obnoxious protagonist. Where as Amuro for better or worse felt like he had legitimate growing up time in the original series, (especially evident when he reappears in this series), Kamille feels like he never gets that. He spends the entire series up until the last ten episodes doing whatever he wants and being pretty whiny, and then in the last ten episodes he just suddenly becomes mature apropos of nothing. This is made worse when other characters start acting like how he did early in the series, and it seems like there's no self reflection for Kamille as a character, instead he chides their behavior even though he was doing the same thing a dozen episodes ago. Suffice to say I'm not a huge Kamille fan.
Now I've heard lots of people say this is their favorite Gundam or say that it's one of the best and honestly I am baffled by that. there are parts of this show that seem truly abysmal. The trick of "Oh No! I love someone but I'm their my enemy!" is done multiple times in this series and is always done poorly. You never get the time you need to see a true attachment form to make this trick effective. (For a great and heartbreaking example of this may I now point you towards 0080 War in the Pocket). Scirocco is kind of a poor antagonist who was almost cool, I think they just needed to lean more towards either super intelligent manipulator or 'this dude's got mind control abilities', but teetering between the two was ineffective. Also once again, kids get slapped around SO MUCH.
Yet at the same time this show has some great moments and great characters. Almost all of the old White Base characters coming back in some way and seeing how time has changed them is really excellent, (you got to love Quattro Bajeena AKA Char Aznable wears some sunglasses). His relationship with Haman and her inclusion as a political entity is so good but also so underutilized, she should have been introduced way earlier. Scenes with Char, Haman, and/or Mineva Zabi were all fantastic. New mobile suits were all very cool. Animation is significantly approved and battles are more interesting to watch now.
Compared to the original series which was sort of constantly hovering right between "OK" and "Good", Zeta has moments that are all the way in "Totally Terrible" and others that are way up in "Gundam Great". I wanted to like this one more than I did.
Char's Counterattack: 3/10 Gundams and 0/10 Quattro Bajeenas
I'll try to make this one short. YES FINALLY THE EPIC CONCLUSION OF THE RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN CHAR AND AMURO. Wait, what, we get very little explanation as to the change from Char in Zeta to now? Wait they hardly get any screen time at all? Who's the main character?
OHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHNOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO
In a series with often not great female characters (So far((Emma was good))) Quess really takes the Gundam cake. She just kind of whines and flirts with everyone. Doesn't really have any goal except getting laid? It really befuddles me why we needed this character at all, why couldn't we just have Amuro as our protaginist? If they did it just to have more of the "oh no! I'm fighting someone I love!" thing again then once again they completely failed.
Also we spend no time at all mourning the deaths of Char and Amuro (the film just ends), but we do spend time mourning some character that no one could possibly care about? That all seemed weird. Anyways the final scene of the movie is the only one really worth watching and even then it's a pretty disappointing conclusion. Animation looked good though! So you know. There's that.
0080 War in the Pocket: 9/10 Gundams and 10/10 tears
Just when I was losing hope, thinking "man this franchise is not all that. Sure it's ok, but this must be mostly nostalgia for most people" Then I watched War in the Pocket. I'm pretty sure I remember Austin saying this and Unicorn were his favorites, and boy was he at least right about this one. Finally a Gundam that is antiwar without also on the side glorifying it. Finally a show that gets the "people we love on different sides of the war" thing right. Already I have arrived at a deconstruction of the entire Gundam franchise and I've only just started.
Al is the right way to do a child in war protagonist. Yes he's immature and does things throughout the show that make me want to scream, but with him it comes across as genuine childlike behavior. I think this is due in part to the excellent dynamic between him and Bernie, who compliment each other so well and yet have so many similarities. The show makes use of action so sparingly that anytime it's happening it feels like it means so much more, rather than the "battle every episode" formula of some of the earlier series. The pacing is completely on point and feels just right at six episodes.
And the ending. OH GOD THE ENDING. Every part of it made me want to cry. I feel like this series achieved everything Zeta wanted to in six episodes. Where Zeta ends up nearly killing all of its cast to be the "dark mature robot show", War in the Pocket shows that its not about quantity but quality. I'm still thinking about this shows ending days later, it had such an impact on me.
It has some neat ties to earlier shows which is nice, and I like the perspective it provides to some events in the original series. The animation is fine. The music is a little weird, though I kind of dug it. Though sometimes the music doesn't seem to fit the mood of the moment. The simple musical theme is really good though.
So many great moments. I cannot recommend this show enough, whether you are a Gundam fan or not.
That's all for now! I'd be interested to know some other people's experiences with these series! Try not to spoil future series for me though! See you sometime in the future with part 2, which will contain reviews for Stardust Memory, F91, Victory Gundam, and G Gundam.
Log in to comment