@grimglottis: Can only speak for myself, of course, in relation to the games I mentioned. Not sure I would say "horrible", but definitely boring as hell and not being able to see what is supposedly so great with those games that everyone else/so many others seem to think. The games I listed are also all in genres of games that I otherwise usually love. Black Flag being the only mainline AC game I haven't finished for example as I don't think it's a good AC game, and only okay as a pirate game. The first Mordor game; I have really enjoyed LOTR, read the books, seen the movies and played through a bunch of the decent to mediocre PS2 era games, and I also have loved all the Batman games, even Origins and Arkham Knight. But, Mordor is bad at being both in my opinion. Combat feels worse than Batman and the story doesn't feel like it fits in LOTR at all.
Valve games... Half Life is not a good series. I like a ton of different FPS games, ranging from stuff like Doom, Wolfenstein, COD to Deus Ex and so on, but Half Life feels off. Not an interesting world, don't care for the controls and never really found anything about them impressive in any way other than HL2 having some neat physics for the time it came out. Portal has a humor that generally falls flat for me.
The Bethesda RPGs... My main experience with both series stems from Oblivion and Fallout 3. Worlds I got bored of after a couple of hours in each. I just feel when you have an RPG with a world you should be able to really immerse yourself in you are not doing yourself many favors by having each conversation look like you are talking to a cardboard cutout of a person. Neither does having combat that lacks any kind of impact when you stand there swinging a sword at someone for example. Couple that with a story that feels tacked on and the game ends up having such a lack of direction that it feels more like it should just be a sandbox without anything else attached to it. And I generally love other RPG games of the same ilk, such as the Witcher series.
A lot of repetition there, but oh well, might as well attach a few more points to each as to why I don't like them :P
Log in to comment