So unsure if I should believe the 4 stars and the one or two positive sentences, or the general meh-ness of everything else Jeff has said about this game. At least I know what I'm in for.
Great review --- it convinced me to pick it up. I did find the hitching in PS4 pretty irritating, as it continually broke the immersion the game is so good at creating. My recommendation is to wait a few weeks before playing so they can iron these things out.
lateralex's comments