Something went wrong. Try again later

mfpantst

This user has not updated recently.

2660 0 43 32
Forum Posts Wiki Points Following Followers

Statistical question on spam

Ok so first let me preface what I'm about to say with this:
I am not talking about the psychological motivations.  We could debate that until blue in the face- though I'm willing to bet the simplest answer (they're not that bright) is the easiest answer.
 
I'm asking of the people who post threads that get locked (excepting delete/combine requests- that makes sense), what are the user statistics?  What's the average user post count before a locked thread?  What's the average user subscription age (I mean how long have they been a user) at time of first locked thread?  Of users who get threads locked, what's the average locked thread count for that user (for users with multiple locks counting them as one user with x amount of locks)?
 
There's are psuedo-serious questions.  I'm posting this as a blog because this is what goes through my mind.  I still like to go through and read locked threads.  And while I would expect half of them to be "hi I'm new," way more are you tube spam or other buffoonery.  So today reading them all I began to wonder the statistical picture of the "future locked thread poster", and how they fit with my mental preconception.  Anyways- just some interesting food for thought.
 
On another topic- on Delete/Combine requests- I'm fairly impressed people notice the things they do, but I do wonder what the mental makeup of a wiki-er is?  I like the design and function of wiki's, but for me the editing isn't my bag (tbh I tend to fall to sandbox issues, being able to edit a wiki means I'll eventually commit vandalism) so I stay away from that, but reading through the stuff that's out there is cool and incredibly valuable (for me at least).
 
Ok so weird off-topic thought bubbling done for the day.

4 Comments

4 Comments

Avatar image for mfpantst
mfpantst

2660

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 4

User Lists: 0

Edited By mfpantst

Ok so first let me preface what I'm about to say with this:
I am not talking about the psychological motivations.  We could debate that until blue in the face- though I'm willing to bet the simplest answer (they're not that bright) is the easiest answer.
 
I'm asking of the people who post threads that get locked (excepting delete/combine requests- that makes sense), what are the user statistics?  What's the average user post count before a locked thread?  What's the average user subscription age (I mean how long have they been a user) at time of first locked thread?  Of users who get threads locked, what's the average locked thread count for that user (for users with multiple locks counting them as one user with x amount of locks)?
 
There's are psuedo-serious questions.  I'm posting this as a blog because this is what goes through my mind.  I still like to go through and read locked threads.  And while I would expect half of them to be "hi I'm new," way more are you tube spam or other buffoonery.  So today reading them all I began to wonder the statistical picture of the "future locked thread poster", and how they fit with my mental preconception.  Anyways- just some interesting food for thought.
 
On another topic- on Delete/Combine requests- I'm fairly impressed people notice the things they do, but I do wonder what the mental makeup of a wiki-er is?  I like the design and function of wiki's, but for me the editing isn't my bag (tbh I tend to fall to sandbox issues, being able to edit a wiki means I'll eventually commit vandalism) so I stay away from that, but reading through the stuff that's out there is cool and incredibly valuable (for me at least).
 
Ok so weird off-topic thought bubbling done for the day.

Avatar image for jaktajj
Jaktajj

882

Forum Posts

64

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 7

Edited By Jaktajj
@mfpantst: I can't answer many......or any of your questions, but I'd love to see the stats on relationship advice threads!
Avatar image for melcene
melcene

3214

Forum Posts

1475

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 1

User Lists: 9

Edited By melcene

I think that the results would be skewed.  One thing I often wonder is that of the threads that get locked immediately, where the poster is "new" to the site, how many of those are alter egos of someone who already posts here regularly but is trying to be anonymous?

Avatar image for mfpantst
mfpantst

2660

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 4

User Lists: 0

Edited By mfpantst
@melcene:  So a subsequent question then: what percentage of posters whose threads are banned are also sockpuppets?  I believe that is a discoverable value.