@barrock: was thinking that to myself. So many needless arguments over this category. They really need to scrap - it never breeds interesting conversation. Seems to devolve into poor arguments about nothing.
Great list and glad to see some RDR2 love. It's my favourite game this year and I don't know when we'll get a more fleshed out world than this for a while. The story was a bit of a slog at times, but I took things slow and it felt a lot like life. Hard, unpredictable and difficult to understand sometimes.
I know it won't get a crack at GOTY, but Arthur Morgan might be the best character I've come across in a video game..ever?
Hoping this category gets cut next year. Had to drop out after about 25-30 minutes - really don't want to listen to the group figure out what the category even is and bicker.
The Dan episodes work when you take the "Enemy Within" literally. I don't have that much of a problem with the shtick when the missions don't go completely pear shaped, but I don't mind it that much. It's almost more fun to have the different play styles and knowing you're going to get a train wreck episode haha
nick_verissimo's comments