
*Two months late maybe, but that is how my school newspaper rolls. I wrote this for it over the weekend and decided to post it here too. ;)
“By reinterpreting an essential symbol of one generation in the medium and technology of another, The Beatles: Rock Band provides a transformative entertainment experience. In that sense it may be the most important video game yet made.”
Seth Schiesel, the New York Times video game critic, declared this upon the release of The Beatles: Rock Band on September 9, 2009. In the field of journalism, this type of statement is viewed as hyperbole. And it is. However, Schiesel makes a somewhat valid point here about the importance of this new release. By blending icons of two generations (Beatles for old; video games for current), The Beatles: Rock Band is a far more important release for both music and video games than the fifth Guitar Hero or another Rock Band featuring LEGOs (yes, there is one).
But first, a short history. Practically every human being on the planet with an ear for popular music is aware of The Beatles. From their Liverpool days to the final rooftop concert they performed in London, The Beatles defined a generation and remain one of the most influential acts on the planet. John, Paul, George and Ringo created immortal albums such as Sgt. Pepper and Rubber Soul that remain ingrained into the public consciousness today. Thus, this Rock Band release is significant in its ability to bring The Beatles’ music to those who may not be that acquainted with their music already.
Nonetheless, the only thing people want to know is whether or not the game lives up to the hype or not. To an extent, it certainly does. The tried and true Rock Band formula is brought here with little change to the fundamental structure but many tweaks to the aesthetic style. The game is bright and organic, unlike many of the dark, dimly lit venues from Rock Band 2. The most famous venues of the Beatles’ career serve as backdrops for the songs, including the Cavern Club in Liverpool, Shea Stadium and Budokan. Once the Beatles moved past touring and fully divulged their creative element, they settled at Studio 2 in Abbey Road, which is where most of The Beatles: Rock Band takes place at. Here, each song starts in their expansive studio then
transforms into a “dreamscape” based off the song that is being played. For instance, “Yellow Submarine” will feature nautical scenery such as huge waves and, of course, a yellow submarine. All of the songs at Abbey Road have an individual scene and while some of them are drab (“Getting Better” is merely flashing lights and Sgt. Pepper garb), the dreamscapes really set this experience apart from any other music game out there and really make this game a loving tribute to the band that brought so much to the world.
Furthermore, the set list is stellar even if it misses some key tracks. All points of their career are touched upon, starting with “I Saw Her Standing There” and ending with, well, “The End.” “Dear Prudence” is a blast to play on any instrument, with difficult hammer-ons for guitar, a steady groove for bass, complex fills for drums and a soulful vocal part. Speaking of vocals, there is an innovative (and somewhat overdue) addition brought to this game: 3-part harmonies. As any Beatles fan knows, much of the magic behind their songs lies in the layered harmonies between John, Paul and George. For this game, three different microphones can be plugged in for different participants to attempt to harmonize with one another. It is not easy to do but it is very
satisfying when the chorus of “I Want To Hold Your Hand” is mastered with a group of people. While vocals are obviously tough merely because of the voices behind the songs, the rest of the difficulty on the instruments are a considerable knock down from other Rock Band/Guitar Hero games. The Beatles were not the technical masters of their instruments like Eric Clapton and Keith Moon of the day even if they still rank up there with the best. The creativity they had was unequivocal and, thus, why their songs were so captivating. I was able to 5-star nearly every song on Expert Bass or Hard/Expert Guitar, something I am rarely able to do in other games. However, the drums actually remain very challenging, possibly dispelling the naysayers of Ringo’s ability. “I Wanna Be Your Man,” from the early album Meet The Beatles , is shockingly hard, with an erratic beat and intricate rhythm that is laughably difficult. The note patterns on the whole are not as tough as other games but arrive at a good middle ground to cater to newcomers as well as veterans, leaving both parties satisfied in the end.
It is disappointing that such tracks as “Strawberry Fields Forever” and “Hey Jude” are unexplainably absent from the game as well, but they will most likely appear down the road in the form of downloadable content. The full albums of Sgt. Pepper and Rubber Soul are planned to release before the year is over, and Abbey Road already came out with songs like “Maxwell’s Silver Hammer” and “Oh! Darling.” Even with the missing songs, the library included in the game is varied and fun to play, which ultimately means the most in this case.
The Beatles: Rock Band is obviously a labor of love from the folks behind it at Harmonix. Every aspect of this game feels more polished and refined then other music games that have come before it. The fact that this game was made is still somewhat shocking considering Apple Corps, the Beatles’ studio, and their strict protection of the band’s name. They obviously oversaw many of the stages of production, making sure this was not slighting the band in any sense. Apparently they demanded more wind to be added to the final rooftop concert, seeking to capture that chilly day accurately. However, the history in the game is certainly a sugarcoated one, with nary a mention of the forces behind their breakup. Any fan knows those details though, and this game really serves as a tribute to why they were so great in the first place.
Of course, there are many out there who could care less about The Beatles: Rock Band but still eagerly awaited September 9. That reason is because the remasters of The Beatles’ catalog was released on this day as well. Available in two different sets, stereo and mono, The Beatles’ catalog finally received the upgrade it has severely needed.
To those unaware, the 1987 CD versions of The Beatles’ music were released haphazardly in stereo, without much care or attention to detail. Fans for over 20 years have been seeking better forms of their music, found, of course, on vinyl. However, with the new release of these CDs, the LPs may not be the superior alternative anymore. I got an early holiday gift in the form of the mono box set and observed some of the differences between the remasters and the 1987 CDs.
Please Please Me , The Beatles’ debut, features a number of classic tracks but they usually were flat or lacking in energy. This is different with the remasters, with “Twist and Shout” being a great example. John, who recorded this song at the end of a daylong session, barely has any vocal cords left, giving it its famous, raw sound. The detail is fleshed out with this remaster, making it sound much more authentic and close to the original recording. One of my favorite Beatles songs, “Taxman,” was a rather shoddy track previously but is given new life with this facelift. The bass and drums are cranked up and sound drastically different. Some songs even change pitch or tempo, such as “She’s Leaving Home.” Raised a half step and sped up, Paul’s singing sounds more confident and less shaky than before. Listening to these songs on my PS3 hooked to a nice sound system, I really was impressed by the quality and overall vigor the songs captured. Even without a nice sound system, these songs are great on headphones or boomboxes because of the one-channel sound that mono is defined by. Truthfully, most of the changes are small but, overall, they create a new set of recordings that is really greater than the sum of its parts. Mono sounds very different from stereo and my time with the latter has been restricted to online samplings so I cannot properly gauge its quality. However, mono is the biggest jump from the 1987 set so this box set is probably the best way to buy the remasters considering that they are unavailable for individual purchase.
It is not often that a nearly 50-year-old act is given the spotlight in today’s fast-moving society, but The Beatles are no average band. As the top-selling band of all time, there was not much more ground that they needed to cover to gain more recognition or acclaim. However, they are now the feature of the best music game to date, one that is appealing to many who have been unaware of most of their work, as well as serving the ultimate fan service to the millions of loyal fans in the form of the new, remastered box sets. Even after the death of George and John, their influence remains strong. There will never be an act that can rival their impact again, but the fact that we can celebrate their work together, decades later, benefits all of us.



|
|
With The Beatles Again
(X360)
“By reinterpreting an essential symbol of one generation in the medium and technology of another, The Beatles: Rock Band provides a transformative entertainment experience. In that sense it may be the most important video game yet made.” Seth Schiesel, the New York Times video game critic, declared this upon the ...
Reviewed by RHCPfan24 on Nov. 8, 2009
|
1 out of 1 found this review helpful. |
|
|
It doesn't get better than this.
(X360)
Here it is, the best DLC for the game then and still to this day. It may eventually be bested but for now Moving Pictures is the king of album downloadable content. All the instruments are a blast to play, with Geddy Lee's signature vocals and basslines even more fun ...
Reviewed by RHCPfan24 on Aug. 4, 2009
|
1 out of 1 found this review helpful. |
|
|
Not a revolution, but a perfection in survival horror.
(X360)
Distress call from a mining ship in the deep recesses of space. Everything goes haywire upon arriving. Silent protagonist. The opening moments....With these clichés, Dead Space seems to be on the track of mediocrity and will be summarily forgotten, right? Well, thankfully, no, because Dead Space does enough on its ...
Reviewed by RHCPfan24 on May 23, 2009
|
2 out of 2 found this review helpful. |
|
|
A flawed gem.
(PS2)
Killzone had enormous amounts of hype attached to it before it was released in 2004. It was claimed to be a "Halo-killer" and it would be a saving grace for the FPS genre on the PS2. What it ended up being was a big disappointment. However, it is unfair to ...
Reviewed by RHCPfan24 on July 22, 2008
|
1 out of 1 found this review helpful. |
|
|
A simple, excellent sim game.
(PS2)
I have owned this game for many years, and I have logged so many hours into this game that I can't remember the first time I played it. The game may seem simple to some, but if you truly "get it" when you play it, you will agree with me ...
Reviewed by RHCPfan24 on July 22, 2008
|
2 out of 2 found this review helpful. |
|
|
An astonishing package all around.
(X360)
Having won numerous awards at E3 and being surrounded by hype, Call of Duty 4: Modern Warfare already seemed like it would be one of the games of the year. Now that it is finally out, it has lived up to all of its expectations and then some. I have ...
Reviewed by RHCPfan24 on July 22, 2008
|
2 out of 2 found this review helpful. |
|
|
Brilliant, astonishing, just plain amazing!
(X360)
Wow. Once in a while, there will be this one game that is so astonishing that you feel lucky just being to play it. Since Resident Evil 4 debuted on Gamecube two years ago, there has not been one game that I feel has matched it. No I am wrong. ...
Reviewed by RHCPfan24 on July 22, 2008
|
1 out of 1 found this review helpful. |
|
|
It's short, but it is fun.
(X360)
This game is not perfect. It is short, sometimes very repetitive, and the multiplayer is not that good. But it IS fun. Through the approximate six to eight hours you can stretch this game out to, you will have a blast. Featuring a great opening level, players will be immersed ...
Reviewed by RHCPfan24 on July 22, 2008
|
|
|
|
A big disappointment in such a fine series...
(X360)
I loved this game. Emphasis on the past tense. When this game released about 17 months ago, I played it until I beat it and then some. Wow, World War II is fun! Now, nearly 17 months later, I picked it up again and realized, hey, this game is not ...
Reviewed by RHCPfan24 on July 22, 2008
|
|
|
|
Doesn't do the license justice...
(WII)
I really wanted to like this game; I did. Despite reading rather sub-par reviews, I decided to land $50 on this game and I felt disappointed with my purchase. This will appeal to Potter fans (like me), but not really anyone else. On the positive side, Hogwarts is rendered beautifully, ...
Reviewed by RHCPfan24 on July 21, 2008
|
|
| Date Joined: | July 21, 2008 |
| City: | Harrington Park |
| Gender: | Male |
| Alignment: | Neutral |
| Points: | 21,556 Points |
| Ranked: | Ranked #52 of 60,750 |
|
Harry Potter character - 10,491 points |
|
|
Albus Dumbledore character - 4,809 points |
|
|
Severus Snape character - 1,522 points |
|
|
Horcrux concept - 602 points |
|
|
Lucius Malfoy character - 206 points |
|
|
Samuel L. Jackson person - 193 points |
|
|
'Splosion Man game - 159 points |
|
|
Filius Flitwick character - 157 points |
|
|
Dethfish77
5 minutes ago Ugh, I stayed up all night. That's not good. |
|
|
FLStyle
16 minutes ago Instead of A'sC II, Brutal Legend and DiRT2 I'm being sent A'sC II+Tropic Thunder+Terminator Salvation, LoveFilm priority system FTW! |
|
|
TheGamerGeek
19 minutes ago RT @mechberg: Someone stop Zooey Deschanel before she sings again. |
|
|
Kush
42 minutes ago Will be leaving for Microcenter in a bit to try and snag a few 1600MS point cards for $12.99 .... |
|
|
gingertastic_10
48 minutes ago We bowl one of the best teams in the state today along with the defending state champ. Fan-fucking-tastic. |
|
|
TrueEnglishGent
1 hour, 31 minutes ago Stewart Downing as made the bench for the Villa against Burnley, great news. Just hope we don't start him to early. Still recovering. |
|
|
SuperMooseman
1 hour, 35 minutes ago BANNED |
|
|
get2sammyb
1 hour, 47 minutes ago How Hard Is Too Hard Where Trophies Are Involved – “Twiggy” The PushSquare Opinionator http://bit.ly/6uA0lj #playstation #ps3 |
|