When you start enforcing contemporary politics into something that just wants to be a game you are asking for disappointment. That people are asking or hoping to get a serious discussion of modern-day politics from a video game, is absurd. People are reading way too much into these things, more than is reasonable.The fact that the game even brings up trans people is itself a way of progress, since the vast majority of games don't adress it, not even most triple-A games.
A game should not be tailor-made to fit contemporary politics, its spoils the game and turns it into political marketing, nothing more. Most of us just want a good game. "Representation"? sure, but is that what every game should be about, what every storyline must focus on by law? no, that's absurd. The developers should be free to tell the story they want to tell. If we start policing them, like much of the US gaming media is already doing, then there's little point of writing a story or creating characters, beause someonone somewhere is bound to be offended since representation is a subjective feeling, something experienced internally, that has as much to do with the person viewing it as it has the actual material.
On a side-note, let's make a list of a 100 representative groups so that every single video game henceforth ticks every single one of them. Not just that, they have to cover each group 100% perfectly. This is not reasonable however. Or just do what the US media already does, and conveniently apply your ethical principles only on occasion, not for every game you come across but for whenever it suits you. Nobody is talking about representation in Nintendo games. Where are the dark-skinned people in Mario for example? But hey they're Japanese, and the US media only apply their principles for Eastern European games, not American, British, and certainly not Japanese games. This racist targeting of developers from certain regions of the world annoyes me. There's such a clear double-standard in this. I have no issues with these topics per se, I have an issue with how the media applies their scrutiny of it: "for some games - developed in these countries - we care about representation, for other games it's completely irrelevant". That does not add up, cherry-picking is the opposite of having principles.
Log in to comment