There's a lot of good mentions in this thread but a lot of them I managed to dodge since them since the backlash came swiftly enough to temper my expectations. I was sad to hear that Mass Effect Andromeda was poor since I loved the series, so when I fired it up I just tinkered and wasn't shocked when it didn't click with me.
I'm going to upset some folks with this one, but it's Nier: Automata for me.
I really liked the first Nier for what it was, so a sequel by Platinum seemed like a slam dunk. Automata was tedious on every level. The gameplay was more active than the first Nier, to its detriment, but not active or interesting enough. More time wasting quests and running across a big, ugly map that isn't fun to traverse. Actually everything about Nier Automata is ugly, visually. Awful frustrating game design where it would lock you away from the quests while ramping up the level cap or difficulty with no warning (the start of the C play through as the worst offender). Random genre switches done poorly. Garbage checkpoint system. I found myself screaming at my television as I suffered through more and more waves of garbage, poorly communicated, bad game design.
But the story. Oh god the story is just so disappointing. The game gives you no reason or motivation to care about these characters. In fact, the way the story sets them up as disposable right off the bat just leads everything that follows to "oh sure, of course that's what would happen" because everything is so pedestrian. All off the plot twists were so basic and edge lord shit - "wow look how sad we can make these characters" but with nothing to say about its actual themes of purposelessness and existential crises. A lot of unearned moments, like leaving two characters together without ever indicating that they felt anything for each other (in fact one of them is literally programmed to kill the other, also unaddressed in the slightest, just assume she'll fall in love with the boy because that's what happens right, fuck I hate this game). So much wasted potential, caught up in how clever it is.
It's 20 hours of my life that I wasted since I really bought into since literally everyone in the industry but Jeff and a few outliers was saying was totally worth it, and it so, so, so wasn't. I played through every route in the game and by the end I just hated the game, and everything that it stood for, and resented the huge waste of time. What a disappointment after the first Nier.
Log in to comment