Something went wrong. Try again later

Giant Bomb Review

236 Comments

God of War III Review

4
  • PS3

Sony delivers a fittingly epic and savage PlayStation 3 debut for God of War, even if it does little to evolve the formula established by its predecessors.


 Kratos. Son of Zeus. Ghost of Sparta. God of War. Pisces.
 Kratos. Son of Zeus. Ghost of Sparta. God of War. Pisces.

Kratos is a man with serious anger-management issues--issues that he's been violently working out on the entire pantheon of Olympic gods over the course of the last two God of War games, dismembering, disfiguring, and disembowling every god, demi-god, and beast of myth that crosses his path. This hands-on approach to primal scream therapy continues with God of War III, the first in the series designed specifically for the PlayStation 3. God of War has always been a big graphical showcase for Sony, and to this end God of War III doesn't disappoint, using that extra horsepower to bring a phenomenal level of both detail and scale to the game's presentation. While the technology has advanced, the relative shortage of meaningful changes and refinements to God of War's vivisecting gameplay formula means that it's not quite as thrilling as the first (or second) go 'round. Some of these last-gen holdovers make the experience feel less cutting-edge than it might otherwise, though it's still plenty brutal enough to earn the God of War name.  

 

Still playing fast and loose with Greek mythology, God of War III sees Kratos continue on his quest for vengeance against the gods of Olympus, now with his sights set squarely on dear old dad, Zeus. Of course, Kratos can't just walk right up to Zeus, gut him like a trout, and roll credits, so you'll spend most of the ten-or-so hours of God of War III trying to collect the mythical objects that Kratos believes he needs to finish the job. Of course, on the way, Kratos will face off with, and usually murder, whatever significant figures of Greek mythology he didn't already turn into a red smear in the first two games, all in the most unflinchingly graphic, Verhoeven-esque way possible.  

    
 It's called God of War, not God of Friendly Handshakes.
 It's called God of War, not God of Friendly Handshakes.

If God of War III is your introduction to the series, there's a brief video that will basically catch you up to speed, though at this point, all you really need to know is that Kratos is an angry jerk, and pretty much everyone else he encounters is a vindictive, condescending, double-dealing jerk. His bottomless anger seemed justified in the beginning, but his continued insistence to pursue his vengeance at the cost of, basically, the entire known world makes it hard to conjure up much compassion, and makes him seem more like a petulant child than an unrelenting instrument of righteousness. The line between anti-hero and villain can be razor thin, and I occasionally found myself feeling more like I was the antagonist in someone else's story. Kratos is a consistently sadistic son of a bitch, and it's been his sole character trait for so long that certain turns in the story feel unearned. It's hard to tell exactly where the series will go from here--not to say that the ending is anticlimactic, but its gestures towards closure seem... tentative.  

  

The gameplay experience that wraps around this revenge tour doesn't venture too far from the rhythms of the previous God of War games, focusing primarily on contained group fights, mixing it up with some traversal sequences, some lever-pulling and box-pushing puzzles, and some really huge boss fights, with plenty of quick time events to highlight the game's penchant for cinematic flair. The combat is agreeably fast-paced and intense, and I found the default difficulty level to be the almost perfect, providing a hearty challenge while rarely becoming teeth-gnashingly frustrating.

 
 Say
 Say "AAAHRGH!"

In addition to the standard-issue chain blades, you'll unlock a series of weapons and abilities as you progress through God of War III, all of which can be upgraded using the red orbs found inside both treasure chests, and your enemies' chests. I found it kind of odd that two of the alternate weapons you pick up are variations on the basic chain blade motif, which compelled me to pretty much ignore them in favor of the more distinctive Nemean Cestus, a massive pair of lion-headed gauntlets that favor impact over range. Regardless of your weapons of choice, success in battle in God of War III ultimately comes down to diligent use of Kratos' dodge and counter abilities, as well as knowing which of Kratos' plentiful attacks to use on specific enemies or in specific situations, with a certain eye towards crowd control.  

  

Save for a handful of eye-catching sequences that make unique use of the Icarus wings, I found most of the traversal stuff not necessarily bad, but something to fill the downtime in between the administration of savage beatings. For as terrific as God of War III looks--and it is easily one of the best-looking PlayStation 3 games out there right now--there's something vaguely mechanical about the way Kratos shimmies along ledges and swings from his chains.  

  

Similarly, the quick time events are implemented in such a way that I sometimes felt they were drawing my attention away from the flashy camera moves and gruesome acts they were intended to highlight. It's all the stuff that you expect from a God of War game, which I suspect is the very reason why parts of the game feel kind of perfunctory. It's like the developers had a mechanical understanding of the beats they were expected to hit, and focused more on nailing that stuff than pushing the experience somewhere new. 

      Fighting a Titan is like fighting a mountain that hates you.
      Fighting a Titan is like fighting a mountain that hates you.

These issues, however, hardly define the experience of God of War III. No, God of War, as always, is all about vividly grotesque ways in which Kratos fells his enemies, and an incredible sense of scale as you take down one impossibly leviathanic enemy after another. Aside from the flight sequences I mentioned earlier, the most amazing moments in God of War III for me revolved around the Titans, the huge, primitive elder gods that preceded the Olympians. Acting as both enemy and environment, the Titans are the best example of God of War III's capacity to make you feel simultaneously powerful and insignificant, as the camera zooms out from a standard third-person view of Kratos to a perspective that makes him look like a flea on the Titan's back, all in real-time, and all of it looking incredibly sharp. Kratos himself features an impressive level of detail, both during gameplay but particularly in cutscenes, to the point that the other characters can look a little crude by comparison--which, really, says more about how good Kratos looks than anything else. 

 

The beautiful rendering of Kratos' ugliness is what made God of War III a compelling experience for me, despite of the bits that felt unnecessarily slavish to the God of War formula. Even if it's not the best God of War game, it's unequivocally the best-looking God of War to date, and it makes for a wicked showpiece for the PlayStation 3.

236 Comments

Avatar image for handlas
handlas

3414

Forum Posts

18

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 1

Edited By handlas
@DrLove said:
" @awheaten said:

"   This is a really poor review. This game is nothing but perfect. If you can give dark knight a perfect score, then you should definitely give this one a perfect score. This is hands down game of the year material. Really, Brad Shoemaker is the only non bias guy out the group. My loyalty to this site has gone down. I just can't shake the feeling that if this game was on the 360, it would have gotten a perfect score. I don't know if you guys are madd at the price that Sony initially came out with or the fact that this is a Japanese company that is competing with an American company. But, all of you guys, Jeff, Vinny, and Ryan are all bias towards M$ Xbox. Its becoming more apparent the more I listen to these podcasts.  I just can't believe this.     "

ya its not like killzone 2, Rachet, uncharted 2, MGS4, infamous  and LBP got 5/5.. oh wait.. "
and yet the funny thing is....GoW3 is better than all those games you have listed.  Different genres...whatever tho.
Avatar image for drlove
DrLove

449

Forum Posts

37

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 1

Edited By DrLove
@awheaten said:
" @DrLove:   

 ya its not like killzone 2, Rachet, uncharted 2, MGS4, infamous  and LBP got 5/5.. oh wait..  


   
  Yeah, but, there never is a general consensus among the group on these games. Also, DrIdiot I mean DrLove, MGS4 wasn't GOY as it should have been. Jeff and Vinny was very against making Uncharted GOY. I don't even think Jeff played Little big Planet.. oh wait.. Even Gamespot gave these game good ratings. Guess they felt a little pressure.   Go sit down some where DrLove, these guys lean towards the Xbox more than a nettle on a record player. "   
  umm i am sitting, generally thats what ppl do when they use computers...  anyway my point was many different ps3 games from different genres all got 5's on this site where they " lean toward the xbox.." what was the last xbox game that got a 5 that you thought got it unfairly?? 
Avatar image for lebart
LeBart

307

Forum Posts

121

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 1

User Lists: 2

Edited By LeBart

You guys suck... 
In which planet do you live where 4 out of 5 is a bad score ? Even if it was anyway, why should Ryan not give his honest impression on the game ? As I recall, someone close to Ryan got fired for giving a game a bad review (although that never was confirmed but nevermind), and I seem to remember everyone being outraged by the fact that he could not give an honest opinion. 
 
The Internet is way worst than publisher pression. IT'S WAY LOUDER !

Avatar image for jazzmaverick
JazzMaverick

108

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

Edited By JazzMaverick

Ha ha... i knew after seeing the score that the comments would be like this... omg 4/5 ???... you can't be serious,this is GoW III,a Ps3 exclusive ... it should be 5/5. ; )
 
If they can give Fallout 3 a 4/5 then a samey button masher should be happy to get the same imo.

Avatar image for drowsap
drowsap

744

Forum Posts

10

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

Edited By drowsap

i never got in to the gow games they were just to button mashy

Avatar image for afroman269
Afroman269

7440

Forum Posts

103

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 6

Edited By Afroman269

lol people are still continuing to bitch about this score. Thank you Ryan. Reading these comments are great. 

Avatar image for twoonefive
TwoOneFive

9793

Forum Posts

203

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 1

Edited By TwoOneFive

there are more people making fun of fanboys on here than actual fanboys getting angry about this. you guys are really all talking to yourselves. 

Avatar image for darknaut
darknaut

128

Forum Posts

11

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

Edited By darknaut
@awheaten said:
"   This is a really poor review. This game is nothing but perfect. If you can give dark knight a perfect score, then you should definitely give this one a perfect score. This is hands down game of the year material. Really, Brad Shoemaker is the only non bias guy out the group. My loyalty to this site has gone down. I just can't shake the feeling that if this game was on the 360, it would have gotten a perfect score. I don't know if you guys are madd at the price that Sony initially came out with or the fact that this is a Japanese company that is competing with an American company. But, all of you guys, Jeff, Vinny, and Ryan are all bias towards M$ Xbox. Its becoming more apparent the more I listen to these podcasts.  I just can't believe this.     "
God forbid, a reviewer may not agree with your opinion on a game. If you're so sure that the game is great, why does a review matter? Reviews are general baselines for you, the player, to go off of when making your purchase decision, not a proclamation to the greater world about whether or not the game would equate to an Oscar winning film. God of War is God of War - it did its job, and well at that, but it's still God of War and for the series' final entry, it didn't bring anything new in. Instead, it just kept to the same, refined formula, bravado, and shine that we've come to expect. Four stars for your favorite game is good.
   
But that's okay, keep deluding yourself into thinking that this has anything at all to do with a Japanese company, which console it was on, a bias, or anything other than what some dude thinks about a game he played. Guess what? Your opinion that it's worthy of five stars is as valid as his that it warrants four - the difference is that yours is clearly biased. 
 
People piss me off.
Avatar image for topraman517
topraman517

11

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

Edited By topraman517

 Man, if this was IGN, fanboys would be having a fit.  That site gave this game a 9.3, and all the fanboys were calling IGN biased towards the Xbox 360 for giving too LOW a score.
 
Anyway, I think the criticisms in this review are valid.  I know many people are okay with more of the same, when it is from a series as good as God of War.  However, some people, such as myself, prefer that each iteration in a series be distinct from the previous iterations.  That being said, God of War 3 is one of the few exceptions for me.  I played the demo, and the presentation of the game is just phenomenal.  Plus, the game is so over-the-top in its violence and aggression that it's hilarious.  I still haven't played GoW 2, but I don't remember the first game being this funny. 

Avatar image for copycatzen
copycatzen

819

Forum Posts

51

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 2

Edited By copycatzen

I want my Video Review!!!!!! 
btw.. it should have been 5 stars
Avatar image for awheaten
awheaten

11

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

Edited By awheaten
@Darknaut:  
 
 

God forbid, a reviewer may not agree with your opinion on a game. If you're so sure that the game is great, why does a review matter? Reviews are general baselines for you, the player, to go off of when making your purchase decision, not a proclamation to the greater world about whether or not the game would equate to an Oscar winning film. God of War is God of War - it did its job, and well at that, but it's still God of War and for the series' final entry, it didn't bring anything new in. Instead, it just kept to the same, refined formula, bravado, and shine that we've come to expect. Four stars for your favorite game is good.
   
But that's okay, keep deluding yourself into thinking that this has anything at all to do with a Japanese company, which console it was on, a bias, or anything other than what some dude thinks about a game he played. Guess what? Your opinion that it's worthy of five stars is as valid as his that it warrants four - the difference is that yours is clearly biased. 
 
People piss me off.    

Listen I never said that my feelings about this game was bias, it is. And that my opinion of his review (Ryan's review) was just that, my opinion. My point is that, IF this was an Xbox game, the crew would be so engulfed in talking about how awesome it is and things like that. YOU KNOW, they would have given this game 5 stars. Thats the point. Look at all of the 3rd party games. Listen to the podcasts. The crew, for the exception of Brad, did not want to give any of Sony's games, especially this year, GOY award. The arguments were so bogus. Uncharted was most definitely GOY material. Jeff and Vinny, I think they're more honest about not liking Sony. But, Ryan was very reluctant and objective when it came to admitting that Uncharted was game of the year. 
 
Also, who gives a game a low score because of the character's mood. Dude, that is totally bogus. Saying that Kratos is madd all the time is not a good take. Also, I'm not buying that "God of War doesn't bring anything new to the series". Its an action game. If it brought anything new, it wouldn't be an action game, it would be... I don't know Metal Gear or Final Fantasy (which the crew is also negative towards. Can't wait to see the review for FF13).  
 
Anyway, get your facts straight. And don't put me on blast bc these guys are bias. Its ok. Its their website. However, this is a bias website. And though I've follow these guy's career for a long period of time. I they are about to loose me bc of their bias attitude against Sony is taking away from their otherwise good info.
Avatar image for obcdexter
obcdexter

999

Forum Posts

3

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 17

Edited By obcdexter
@awheaten said:
Listen I never said that my feelings about this game was bias, it is. And that my opinion of his review (Ryan's review) was just that, my opinion. My point is that, IF this was an Xbox game, the crew would be so engulfed in talking about how awesome it is and things like that. YOU KNOW, they would have given this game 5 stars. Thats the point. Look at all of the 3rd party games. Listen to the podcasts. The crew, for the exception of Brad, did not want to give any of Sony's games, especially this year, GOY award. The arguments were so bogus. Uncharted was most definitely GOY material. Jeff and Vinny, I think they're more honest about not liking Sony. But, Ryan was very reluctant and objective when it came to admitting that Uncharted was game of the year.  Also, who gives a game a low score because of the character's mood. Dude, that is totally bogus. Saying that Kratos is madd all the time is not a good take. Also, I'm not buying that "God of War doesn't bring anything new to the series". Its an action game. If it brought anything new, it wouldn't be an action game, it would be... I don't know Metal Gear or Final Fantasy (which the crew is also negative towards. Can't wait to see the review for FF13).   Anyway, get your facts straight. And don't put me on blast bc these guys are bias. Its ok. Its their website. However, this is a bias website. And though I've follow these guy's career for a long period of time. I they are about to loose me bc of their bias attitude against Sony is taking away from their otherwise good info. "
Bias you call them, but that doesn't make them.
Like you mentioned they DID award a PS3 exclusive title GOTY 2009, they DID a Persona 4 endurance run, which, to my knowledge, is also Playstation exclusive. Yes, they definitely play XBOX games more - that's safe to say. Like most people in this business they tend to get XBOX versions of multi-platform games earlier, so, can you really blame them?
God of War is a 4-star game in Ryan's mind. What the effin' hell is wrong with that? 
General dislike towards Sony ... yeah, you know, that's something weird only a Sony-fanboy could come up with (and vice versa). But that's just my opinion and by no means I'll label it the only valid one. I just feel that way reading your comments.
 
As far as I'm able to tell, Ryan is not a big fan of these types of games, still he ended up awarding it a very good rating with only few negatives pointed out. It is absolutely a recommendation in the end, wouldn't you agree?
Personally, I hardly agree on any reviews I find online, in magazines or elsewhere. They often tend to be either too positive or too negative. On here only very rarely I come across such "love-letters" or rants.
And again: This very review can't possibly be the reason for your complaints. It's a damn good rating with the right amount of praise for this game. Five stars if it had been an XBOX game? No way. Never. That's just bad-mouthing the crew.
Avatar image for man_flannel
MAN_FLANNEL

2472

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

Edited By MAN_FLANNEL
@obcdexter: 
I wouldn't waste the keystrokes with that kid.  Apparently he stops by Giantbomb once a year to defend Sony exclusives from the "Xbot" staff.
Avatar image for awheaten
awheaten

11

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

Edited By awheaten
@obcdexter:  
 
 

God of War is a 4-star game in Ryan's mind. What the effin' hell is wrong with that?      

My last time repeating myself, it wouldn't have been if it was on the Xbox. 
 

General dislike towards Sony ... yeah, you know, that's something weird only a Sony-fanboy could come up with (and vice versa). But that's just my opinion and by no means I'll label it the only valid one.    

I am a fan boy, fool. Doesn't make my complaint any less valid. This isn't the first time this has happened. All 3rd party games are really just Xbox exclusive, at least in my mind. 3rd party games gets so much praise for being better on the 360. And thats just the truth. C'mon Dark Knight had no business going up against Uncharted 2.  Maybe Killzone or something, oh thats right that would have been 2 PS3 games against each other.
 

Ryan is not a big fan of these types...


Thats right, what the HELL is he doing reviewing this game. 
  
In Conclusion, I'm a fan of Jeff, Ryan, and Brad. Really, don't know Vinny that well. He seems to me not to even like video games. He seems to like to hit some weed though. But I'm not bad mouthing the crew. I'm simply commenting on Ryan's review... AND IT SUCKED!
Avatar image for august
august

4106

Forum Posts

332

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

Edited By august
@awheaten:  Of course being a fanboy makes your opinion invalid. That's the basic definition of being a fanboy. You're a partisan nutjob so emotionally invested in your system and company of choice that you see bias and conspiracy everywhere. You might as well come to a political debate wearing clown shoes.
Avatar image for dawglet
Dawglet

317

Forum Posts

5

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 12

Edited By Dawglet
@awheaten said:
 All 3rd party games are really just Xbox exclusive, at least in my mind. 
You need help.
Avatar image for demontium
demontium

5084

Forum Posts

1801

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 7

User Lists: 5

Edited By demontium

GREAT review Ryan!

Avatar image for awheaten
awheaten

11

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

Edited By awheaten
@demontium:  
@DrLove:
 
@Darknaut:  
 @
obcDexter: 
@Man_Flannel: 
@Dawglet: 
@august 
@Demontium 
 
IF YOU GUYS WERE STDs, RYAN's BALLS WOULD BE ITCHING RIGHT NOW.   Let the man be wrong about a reweiw people, Damn!?
Avatar image for demontium
demontium

5084

Forum Posts

1801

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 7

User Lists: 5

Edited By demontium
@awheaten said:
" @demontium:  
@DrLove:
 
@Darknaut:  
 @
obcDexter: 
@Man_Flannel: 
@Dawglet: 
@august 
@Demontium 
 
IF YOU GUYS WERE STDs, RYAN's BALLS WOULD BE ITCHING RIGHT NOW.   Let the man be wrong about a reweiw people, Damn!?
"
Oh I see, we are not allowed to agree with a review we see correct.  
 
Sounds great.... Piss off. This game is great- wait you probably just looked at the score didn't you. 
 
Well if you actually did read it (which is doubtful) you should know that its very well worded and very correct. 
 
Stop being a one minded fan or get off this site.  
Avatar image for luce
luce

4056

Forum Posts

39

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 4

Edited By luce
-------And now a brief intermission brought to you by Del monte Fashion peas -------
 
 
 
 
 

No Caption Provided

 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
-------Your regularly scheduled fanboy rage will now continue------
Avatar image for dietmango
dietmango

1795

Forum Posts

35751

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: -4

User Lists: 13

Edited By dietmango

See, this is why the rating system sometimes doesn't or shouldn't even matter. In fact, it's distracting (just read the comments on this review, for example). But then again, you kind of need a score so that countless idiots who don't know the definition of 'read' will actually pay attention to it.
 
I'd say this is a well-written review by Ryan. I can't agree with some of his points because my time with God of War III was incomplete, so I don't know how I would feel about the game's ending because I've never gotten that far yet. I do agree that it is one of the best-looking games on the PS3, no doubt about it. However, he's right about the gameplay mechanics being basically the same thing, albeit refined or whatever.
 
Wow, so people are saying Giantbomb is biased against the PS3? Talk about ignorant (stupid) and pathetic. Those who think that can shut up and go fuck themselves. It's better that way than having people bitch and moan every single time they disagree with what a reviewer has to say, no matter how honest and critical it is.

Avatar image for etch
Etch

8

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

Edited By Etch

  " Kratos  is a man with serious anger-management issues--issues that he's been violently working out on the entire pantheon of Olympic gods over the course of the last two God of War games, dismembering, disfiguring, and disembowling every god, demi-god, and beast of myth that crosses his path. " - Ryan Davis of GiantBomb.com 
 
This should be on the box. This quote would sell games.    

Avatar image for automaticsnake
AutomaticSnake

404

Forum Posts

9

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 6

User Lists: 2

Edited By AutomaticSnake

lol they have given crappy games a 4, now GoW3 get a 4... giant bomb one of the worst review sites ever.

Avatar image for gouveia
gouveia

19

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

Edited By gouveia

everyone already knows Ryan sucks in hacknslash games as we have seen in dantes inferno, its not hes thing.
honestly someone else should review the game instead of him.

Avatar image for canteu
Canteu

2967

Forum Posts

65

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

Edited By Canteu

Cheers Ryan, nice review. A fun read.
 
@all the nut jobs
SHHHHH

Avatar image for joeltgm
JoelTGM

5784

Forum Posts

1760

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 2

User Lists: 1

Edited By JoelTGM

Good review I guess, but it sounds like you were just looking for negative things to say about, trying to be more professional or something.  I say just play it like a roller coaster ride and have fun, don't look THAT deep into it, it's an action game.  I mean, look at Modern Warfare 2.  5 stars from Jeff, and I agree with that review.  The game made no sense whatsoever, but it was exciting and amazing.  God of War 3 is the same, only more epic in my opinion, and more organized, yet it gets 4 stars.  I know we're not supposed to focus on the rating, but whatever, 4 stars for this incredible game just nags me, I mean what are you supposed to do to get 5 stars, like MW2 or that Banjo Kazooie game? 

Avatar image for copycatzen
copycatzen

819

Forum Posts

51

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 2

Edited By copycatzen

@DOUBLESHOCK said:

"Good review I guess, but it sounds like you were just looking for negative things to say about, trying to be more professional or something.  I say just play it like a roller coaster ride and have fun, don't look THAT deep into it, it's an action game.  I mean, look at Modern Warfare 2.  5 stars from Jeff, and I agree with that review.  The game made no sense whatsoever, but it was exciting and amazing.  God of War 3 is the same, only more epic in my opinion, and more organized, yet it gets 4 stars.  I know we're not supposed to focus on the rating, but whatever, 4 stars for this incredible game just nags me, I mean what are you supposed to do to get 5 stars, like MW2 or that Banjo Kazooie game?  "

 

Listen to this fine gentleman.
Avatar image for the_pink
the_pink

14

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

Edited By the_pink

i loved gow3 but i think 4/5 bout' right good review
Avatar image for apollobob
ApolloBob

577

Forum Posts

789

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 5

Edited By ApolloBob

"I say just play it like a roller coaster ride and have fun, don't look THAT deep into it"
 
That's not what a reviewer does - that's what a player does.  When you read about what Ryan considers the game's flaws and decide that "more of the same" etc.. doesn't bother you, then great - enjoy your own personal 5-star roller coaster ride.  But to claim that Ryan doesn't really think there are flaws, but feels like he must find some, is presumptuous if not insulting.
 
Game reviews are supposed to present a critical eye.  If the crew of Giant Bomb reviewed games with the OMG TEH GOD OF WAR AUTOMATIC 5 STARZZZZZZ!!!!!!! attitude of some of you, I'd stop reading their reviews just as automatically.  I really do not understand the personal investment some of you make in wanting all reviewers to march lockstep to your viewpoints.
 
Of course then again I also really don't understand why I am wasting my time trying to argue with Internet.

Avatar image for doolz
Doolz

12

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

Edited By Doolz

good review. i agree almost completely with it.

Avatar image for gilbertcapulong
GilbertCapulong

3

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

Edited By GilbertCapulong

Loved the game. Ate it up in a week. The thing was I also went back and purchased the GOW collection that included GOW 1 and 2 just a month ago and played through them in 2 weeks. I may understand the low points of the game of not being very different but I didn't expect or necessarily want anything changed. I loved GOW 1 and 2 and am really glad the formula wasn't changed but just improved upon.

Avatar image for rugripper40
rugripper40

60

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

Edited By rugripper40

if it aint broke...dont fix it....lol...look what they did to ff13 and c and c trying to evolve the franchise...they freaking ruined it....what a trilogy god of war is...fk yeah
Avatar image for deactivated-5c7ea8553cb72
deactivated-5c7ea8553cb72

4753

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 5

User Lists: 0

@AutomaticSnake said:

" lol they have given crappy games a 4, now GoW3 get a 4... giant bomb one of the worst review sites ever. "

Wait so just because you dont agree, their points are automatically stupid and invalid?
Avatar image for rynmls
rynmls

6

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 1

User Lists: 1

Edited By rynmls

best action game franchise

Avatar image for mormonwarrior
MormonWarrior

2945

Forum Posts

577

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 15

User Lists: 21

Edited By MormonWarrior

I have to say I'm not at all impressed by the visual style of this game. Something about it...I dunno, it just kinda looks really bad to me. Technically and artistically. I actually think the PS2 games look better because there's just something...off about the appearance of this game. I can't put my finger on it. I've played through quite a bit of the game and it can't seem to hold a totally steady frame rate, and the way things move is a little odd...or stuff is too shiny, or something. I don't know what it is, but I think this game looks bad. There.

Avatar image for mormonwarrior
MormonWarrior

2945

Forum Posts

577

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 15

User Lists: 21

Edited By MormonWarrior

@awheaten: This is a long time after the fact, but I'm just looking at these comments, and you couldn't possibly be more deluded about the leanings of the GB crew. About mid-2008 on the Bombcast they'd get questions about whether to buy a PS3 or a 360 given that one could only buy one or the other and given price range, games available, features, etc. They unanimously went with the PS3 because by that point, after price drops and the release of MGS4 and others, it was a more full-featured system for the same price. They tend to be pretty level-headed and keep things fair. Because they've been invested in their gamertags on 360 longer and lots of third-party games work better on it, as well as the fact that they tend to receive review copies for 360, not PS3, they all tend to play the 360 more often. Not so much a bias as much as general acceptance of the way things are. 360 is the PS2 of this generation - most support, most games, earliest release, games are usually developed for it first and ported later to PS3 and PC, biggest install base, etc. etc.

So calm the heck down. Thanks.