@Hungry said:
I can't believe I signed up just to respond to this question. Hello everyone!
So Persona 3 Portable is really damn good. The female main character has very well-written social links and her soundtrack is pretty bangin' too. However, I do want to say that for your first playthrough of Persona 3 I heavily recommend playing either the base game or Persona 3 FES. I say this because P3P removed a lot of design decisions for the sake of smoother gameplay (and to emulate Persona 4) that actually kind of weakens the game, in my opinion.
So in Persona 3, and a little bit in Persona 4 as well, they try really hard to make you feel like you are playing as your character. You walk around and talk to everyone by yourself, there is no magic pocket your party members are put into, and they all have their own schedules throughout the week. That is pretty well displayed in Persona 3, where different characters will greet you when you come back to the dorm, but Persona 3 tries to hit that sense that you are playing as your character in other ways that Persona 4 does not, but also makes the gameplay side of things less smooth.
So in Persona 3 there are a lot of annoying gameplay nuances that have no reason to exist purely from a gameplay point-of-view. Ever since RPGs were invented you could configure your party's inventory through a menu. In Persona 3 you have to talk to the character and then you can access their equipment from there. This is also true if you need them to heal for you, and you can't try and optimize their healing usage. Similarly, characters will look at your inventory and equip items that they think are better (even if an item that gives Yukari resistance to electricity is more powerful than any other item she can wear) and will not tell you until you talk to them. You also cannot directly control your allies, instead you can give them roles and suggestions on what they should be doing. Again, while this is frustrating for gameplay and probably why it was removed in Persona 4 and in Persona 3 Portable, it drove home the theme that you are only playing as your character. Again, RPGs have done all of the things that were changed in Persona 4 before, so it was a design decision by the developers, not an engine or technical limitation.
So in short, I believe you should play Persona 3 or Persona 3 FES first, because it was the way the designers originally intended to convey the story and world to you. There is also the animated cutscenes and walking around which is not present in Persona 3 Portable, which I really missed when I played as the lady protagonist.
PS: I also forgot to mention that the menu screen in Persona 3 takes a second or two to pop up, but is lightning fast in Persona 3 Portable, that can be frustrating but I believe it is worth that little hassle.
See, I have to disagree with this: I've played Persona 3 Portable, and I never felt like I wasn't playing as my character. I mean, you are the leader of the group so it makes sense you would be equipping the others with what you think is best, and telling them what to do in combat. Honestly, if someone just did what they wanted while I'm in charge I would probably just kick them until they fell back in line.
@Nightriff: At the end of the day, I really don't think the changes are that substantial to really say one is definitely better over the other. I prefer P3P because of the female character and direct control over the characters. The story is great either way, and I really didn't miss the animated cutscenes once. I started playing P3P just to take a look at it (I was going to play like an hour, put it down, and go back to whatever else I was playing at the time), and I ended up playing it straight through for 80 hours (with sleep and what not, but it became the main game I played at the time).
But now for the most important question: what exactly are you doing that you can bring a PS3 and a T.V. into your job and use it? I know people who work with a computer often have facebook running in the background, but that's taking it to another level. Finally, if you already own FES why not give it a try? Play it for an hour or two and see what you think. If you start thinking "this is cool, but I wish I could control the characters directly" you'll have a better answer. It's kind of hard for us to say which is better, because it really does come down to personal preference.
Log in to comment