Now, I say hate, but I feel that he will grow very tired and impatient with this game. Being a 40K fan, there were a few points where I was wondering myself why the singleplayer felt that it was dragging a bit. The story is not the greatest, and since the combat can get very repetitive during the middle parts of this game, I have a feeling that Jeff is not going to show any kind of praise towards the game other than the mechanics being sound.
Assuming he'll be the one reviewing it (according to the bombcast), I believe it will get 2-3 stars. Don't get me wrong, I'm not hating or saying that he sucks for not being a fan, it's just that it would take a fan (like me) to appreciate the game a little more than any average dude wanting an action game. The tidbits of lore about the inquisition, the things the orks say, or even the style of how everything looks (how 40K is supposed to look) impressed me more than how the game progressed.
So, this being just a guess, I'll just leave it at that. I just finished it and thought i'd share my thoughts. So, even if you haven't finished it, how are you guys liking the game?