This is my favourite comment by kwintox from that review "My god man.. how can you give it a 6.0 when Multiplayer.it, ausgamers, the escapist and IGN all rate it higher then 8 and when the user score is a 9.3? Aren't you supposed to give objective reviews on games, this felt like you personally didn't like the game thus giving it a undervalued score."
Now, correct me if you think I'm wrong, but isn't personal experience a big part of a review? I personally didn't like New Super Mario Bros. Wii and would have given it a 5 or a 6 our of 10, but that does not make my experience invalid, nor does it make my review (if I had written one) invalid as well. Who cares what other sites are saying about a game? Does it really matter that IGN rated it at 8 when Eric Neigher found the game to be of mediocre quality? I remember Brad having a problem reviewing Steel Battalion: Heavy Armor because he remembered the demo game being good but the final product sucking, and he thought there may have been an issue with Kinect, not the game. Of course it turned out that the game was busted, but what if it wasn't? What if Brad had given it a 1 star despite it not being broken? Or Jeff with Dance Central 3 and his Kinect problems. Or how about Alex's review for NBA 2K13 versus what Vinny and Jeff experienced with the really bad stuff in the quicklook? Does that make either parties' opinions invalid? No, of course not. A review comes down to personal experience and taste. If a game wasn't fun to the one reviewing it, then why would that reviewer score the game high just because someone else did despite their experience with the game totally sucking? It's nothing new to see people on the internet with an intense sense of self-entitlement who think that someone's professional opinion should be pulled because it doesn't agree with theirs, but what I don't get is that people see this as alright behaviour. They can choose to disagree, but the hatred towards the contesting opinion is unwarranted. Though that's a problem with the internet that I don't think will ever go away.
Thankfully I'm glad to be a part of the Giantbomb community in which the majority of the users realize that there are people writing these reviews and providing us with content.
Log in to comment