PenguinNerd

I own both and have to say Demon's Souls.  I've only played through two Fallout 3 DLC (Point lookout and Broken Steel) but while point lookout worked pretty well broken steel was literally plagued with bugs.  It may be somehow different with the GOTY edition but I somehow doubt it.  Demon's Souls (15 hours in right now) has so far been my favorite 15 hours of gaming this whole year.  The difficulty I feel is just right and I've yet to get frustrated at all.  
 
Also you've already beat Fallout 3 so you should totally get Demon's Souls ;)

I'm absolutely loving it so far.  I don't find it frustrating at all just because I love the gameplay enough to make going through the levels over and over again fun.  I'm 15 hours in and while the game is challenging it's not "cheap" so when you do die (at least for me it's this way) you'll want to figure out what you did wrong and how to fix that mistake.  Personally I think it's compelling enough to keep me into it for multiple new game +'s (this coming from someone who very rarely plays through a game twice) but I'm not you.  Watch some videos and the quick look.  If you like the look of the fighting then I say go for it.  The game can be punishing but it's much more rewarding when you overcome the obstacles before you.  However if you're not sure about it, I'd say hold off on getting it.  There's going to be a lot coming out very soon and it might detract from Demon's Souls.  I have to say I completely agree with what Dave said in the quick look in that this is a game he'd get during the down time of games releasing.  So if you plan on getting a lot of games coming up soon maybe hold off a little while until there's not a whole lot coming out?

It's frozen once for me...can't say I didn't expect this to happen though.

Not sure how this will turn out but I did like the old Socom games....

Yeah, I'm not even going to try to figure out what this is....if it somehow has something to do with Dragon quest it'll be the happiest day of my life but...I'm not getting my hopes up.  Also that smiley thing scares me...

" I love how people make these mock ups and the online world go crazy over them.  Technical limitations would be a bitch for it, think how long it takes to see trophy data if you view their card now.  Sure that looks neat, but I don't want to wait 5 - 10 seconds and see a shiity swirly loading icon every time I look at a different person on the list. "

" If it ever comes out for realsies then I'll take a look, but I seem to remember thinking that this game was overpriced. "

@sgjackson: lol no problem :P  I was browsing the NeoGAF thread on this same subject and someone posted the pic so I figured I'd post it here since I saw you mentioned it.

" I wish I knew where the flowchart of the community reaction to recent Sonic games was. From memory, it goes something like this.Game is announced.  It's hailed  (and marketed) as A RETURN TO FORM, forums say "This could be it, he's coming back this time."  General optimism.  A couple of months pass.  More info on the game comes out. We hear about the crazy Final Fantasy story and cutscenes, the werehog, the King Arthur sword. Fans are split - some saying Sega will never learn, some are still cautiously optomistic.   The game comes out.  Reviews are mediocre at best, forum posters willing to take the plunge are disappointed by how tantalizingly close they were to getting the gameplay right, many people swear off Sonic...until the cycle begins again.  It's because I've seen and experienced that exact cycle for about half a decade now that, until I see that this is a serious attempt at a return to form, I refuse to even get excited about this. "

That logo at the end brings me back.  I've been wanting, and dying for a new 2D Sonic game....I want to be excited...that end with the blacked out logo WANTS me to be excited for this...but considering the past few Sonic games and how I've not been fond of them it's tough.  Here's to hoping...
 
@Shindiggah said:

" I guess that Sonic Rush, and Sonic Rivals no longer exist? xD but still looks pretty cool nonetheless. "