Katherine  100%

" Never trust chicks with drill hair. "

i would have to say  katherine

Catherine for sure, RENEGADE OPTIONS

Catherine, by about 182736163254% I really don't see what anyone finds appealing about Dead-faced McGee.

Katherine, Catherine is more of a one-nighter.

Like Addfwyn said, I'm a sucker for Miyuki Sawashiro, so Catherine's voice is just irresistible to me. Also, I just find her more attarctive even though the blonde bombshell type us not normally what I go for.
 
Though like some others have said, I feel bad for Katherine and she's probably the morally right choice to go for. Also between the dark hair and glasses she's much more my traditional type.
 
In the end Miyuki is the deal breaker for me, so Catherine it is!

Katherine, but Catherine would be more fun, ya know what I mean?

32? That's way too old for me. Catherine it is.

" @TheSeductiveMoose said:

" I'm always "good", so whomever that might be (presumably Katherine). "

As far as I can tell, there is no "good option" (unless you think that continuing to cheat on your childhood friend that's probably pregnant with your baby is a bad thing). I guess it just depends on your values.  I'd go with Katherine. Catherine's a whore. But really, from the game's achievements we can see that there are several endings, two of them consisting of Vincent abandoning both of them ("Loner" endings) so I'd go with that. "

Team Katherine represent

Based on just looks, I like Catherine a bit more. I really don't know how I'm gonna deal storywise, especially since the copy I ordered is Japanese.

K all the way

" Damn, have you played it enough to know she's like that or is it just deep seated misogyny? "

I guess I would go for Katherine with a K. Because I have a feeling the other Catherine is probably a whore and/or behind the horrible things that are happening to Vincent. Also the glasses and the long hair do it for me.

"@audiosnag:  I was considering putting a both option, but I got the feeling that 90% of everyone would just have picked it. Thus, I force the choice.  I actually am one of those people that prefers Katherine's appearance over Catherine's, so... "

" @Aus_azn said:

"@audiosnag:  I was considering putting a both option, but I got the feeling that 90% of everyone would just have picked it. Thus, I force the choice.  I actually am one of those people that prefers Katherine's appearance over Catherine's, so... "

Not like your profile picture gave it away. "

With a K, by far. 

" The other one's an evil succubus. "

Catherine for sure!

This one's a toughie. Where's the "both" option?

Katherine spelled with a K 420

Just so people know Catherine has no clue that Vincent is dating Katherine.

Katherine. She has got sexy librarian going on.  
 
She is however too old for me. I am Catherine's age but she seems like a whore.

" Well I'd go with Catherine cause I don't want a fucking kid, end of story. Everyone needs to ween off of their animoo fantasies. "

" @Daveyo520: Just so you know Catherin was a virgin before meeting Vincent. "

" @Bocam: She however dresses and acts like a whore. It doesn't mater how many times she had sex really. It's the way she presents herself. It is not something I like. "

I find Katherine a lot more attractive than Catherine, and also I find her personality more appealing.
 
Katherine all the way man, don't see why you would cheat on that.

" @Gahzoo:  Because Katherine's a bitch... "

I think glasses are sexy.

Both, yeah baby!

" @Catolf:  From what I played, no , not really. But I am going the Red route. I've read that in the Blue route Vincent and Katherine's relationship is much more heartwarming so there's that. Saying anymore would be entering spoiler territory. "

Katherine. 
 
Childhood friend who looks like an actual adult woman? 
 
Also, that 360 cover...