A feature that few players would recognize is the Team Building in Dusty Diamond's. Both players, simultaneously, select characters for their team. As there can be only one of each character used, and the players selecting do not have to take turns, there is an absolutely frantic meta-game in simply constructing your roster. One player could take all of the 'good' characters before the other player has even selected one. It's not uncommon for people to create 'house rules' for picking players.
Every character has his or her own unique traits. Some are fast and some are slow. Some can hit really well and others can pitch really well. Some can teleport through a tag and others can... fly.
One thing that did not make the transition from the Japanese game is, all of the characters were mythical monsters or animals. While the US version has a little creativity with a devil and a witch character, the majority of the characters are non-desrcript every day folks. Despite looking normally, all of the characters retain their original stats and powers. That makes it extremely difficult to figure out who is good at what.
In the original version, if you see an elephant most people won't expect him to be extremely quick. When presented with a ninja, a chicken and a sumo wrestler you have the context clues to work out who'd be good at what (the ninja was quick and throws well, the chicken leaps far and catches well and the sumo wrestler annihilates the ball). While not everyone has a unique skills, there are some worth noting...
|Josh||Alien||Can not be tagged out when running between bases. Has to be forced out OR touch a base occupied by an opposing player with a ball.|
|Froggy||Frog||Hops as he runs, but can also move through puddles on certain fields.|
|Casey||Tengu||Instead of jumping for a ball, he'll jump and hover in the air.|
|Stan||Chimp||Can climb outfield walls to steal homeruns.|
|Sid||Chicken||Can dive huge distances while playing defense.|
|Peter||Snowman||Can bat left or right handed.|
While inconvenient, it does offer the occasional reward to the adventurous captain. Finding that diamond in the rough is often an achievement and is part of the charm of the game. With 60 characters to choose from, there's no shortage of combinations to try.
While every player has his or her own favorite characters, there are some that are clearly suited for specific roles.
|Player||Skills and Stats||Suggested Use|
|Fuji||Powerful hitter, incredibly slow||Catcher, First Base|
|Mikey||All-a-rounder, cannon for an arm||Short Stop, Outfield|
|Louis||Fast runner, good hands||Outfield|
|Slick||Disgustingly quick, solid pitching||Pitcher, Second Base|
|Diablo||Solid batter, little on the slow side||First Base|
Some rules of thumb make building a team fairly simple; Slow guys at catcher and first base, fast guys in the outfield and don't get greedy with the power hitters... it never works.
If the amount of players wasn't enough content, Dusty Diamond's All Star Softball offers an additional mode over the Japanese version; Fast Pitch vs. Slow Pitch. It's not just the speed of the ball that changes, but the overall rules. Much like real softball, when slow pitch is on teams have 4 outfielders and runners can no longer steal bases.
Adding further variety to the game is your choice of 5 fields (Professional makes 6 fields in the 2 player game) each with it's own quirks and rules. The Park has a very short homerun line but no fences so outfielders can chase down extremely well hit balls. Although misplaying a pop fly can lead to easy points. The School is another field that lacks a proper wall or fence, but if you break a window you're automatically out! The Cliff is enclosed like a regular baseball diamond, but with a picket fence in left field. Hit the ball UNDER the fence for a ground rule double. The Park has water hazards, The Island has trees that can interfere with a throw and the Professional is a no-frills playing surface.