because then you get 500 page that say nothing but "this guy is a pokemon/digimon form this game"
just like on the podcast you don't want 500 halo pages you just want one good halo page
I don't think every pokemon or digimon should have its own page
This topic is locked from further discussion.
"I think that they should. If you want to know something about a specific pokemon then it's great."But then again, this is not a Pokedex.systech said:
"Yes, only significant Pokemon should have their own pages like the three starting Pokemon, Pikachu, and of course Koffing."Koffing? LOL
"Homer said:Yes, Koffing."I think that they should. If you want to know something about a specific pokemon then it's great."But then again, this is not a Pokedex.systech said:"Yes, only significant Pokemon should have their own pages like the three starting Pokemon, Pikachu, and of course Koffing."Koffing? LOL"
"Vash_The_Stampede said:GiantBomb staff have said that they want the wiki database to be like an encyclopedia, so listing every pokemon and digimon would be significant in that regard."Homer said:"I think that they should. If you want to know something about a specific pokemon then it's great."But then again, this is not a Pokedex.
that's my point is that it will and does get in the way when I'm trying to look for something I have slog through 500 pokemon pages
and sure it would be valid info if there was info but I've looked at 20 pokemon page that just say "this guy is a pokemon form this game"
and there are hundreds more that say even less
"that's my point is that it will and does get in the way when I'm trying to look for something I have slog through 500 pokemon pagesHow is it getting in the way?
and sure it would be valid info if there was info but I've looked at 20 pokemon page that just say "this guy is a pokemon form this game"
and there are hundreds more that say even less"
It's not like when you're searching for Half-Life Pikachu shows up.
well yeah I'd have no problem with it if there was well written and detailed articles
but I seriously doubt there will even be any and i want fans of pokemon if there are any still any to write well written and detailed articles just to spite me
because then I win and the pokemon fans win
"that's my point is that it will and does get in the way when I'm trying to look for something I have slog through 500 pokemon pagesHow often would you have to? If you're looking for a specific pokemon just type in their name and it wil come up. When you're searching for a game I doubt any pokemon would show up considering there aren't any pokemon named Pokemon.
and sure it would be valid info if there was info but I've looked at 20 pokemon page that just say "this guy is a pokemon form this game"
and there are hundreds more that say even less"
xruntime said:
Personally I think its worthless information, but if someone just has an obsession with Geodude, then they can go write an article about Geodude."I completely agree.
every pokemon is a character in a game, therefore, every pokemon should get a page.
believe me, there's enough useless info on all of them that none of those pages will really be blank
"I think it is fine. If people want to make individual pages for each Pokemon, let them, I see no problem. The more information in the database the better. It's valid information, and it's not like it will get in the way."I concur.
Please Log In to post.
Log in to comment