Giantbomb is a very popular

If you don't believe me check the comments section of Brad's great review of Devil May Cry. You know your site is popular when people hate a review of a game they haven't even played.

Or very idiotic. One of those. (probably both?)

@Winternet said:

Or very idiotic. One of those. (probably both?)

The more smart people there are that discover the site the more... angry and idiotic people there are who follow.

I'm worried about the growing popularity. I don't want the site to attract denizens of cesspools like /v/.

@Salbert said:

I'm worried about the growing popularity. I don't want the site to attract denizens of cesspools like /v/.

The hilarious thing about this mentality is acting like /v/ or any other message board is a hive mind entity. It's not. It's a forum comprised of many different people with a bajillion different opinions. Just like Giant Bomb.

@Salbert said:

I'm worried about the growing popularity. I don't want the site to attract denizens of cesspools like /v/.

just glancing at said review comments, i think we are well passed that.

I liked Giant Bomb before it was cool.

*bans self*

Wow, I didn't even notice until now how many comments that review has. What the hell happened in there? Did Brad talk about sexism or something?

@Oldirtybearon said:

@Salbert said:

I'm worried about the growing popularity. I don't want the site to attract denizens of cesspools like /v/.

The hilarious thing about this mentality is acting like /v/ or any other message board is a hive mind entity. It's not. It's a forum comprised of many different people with a bajillion different opinions. Just like Giant Bomb.

It's not about being a hivemind. It's the ability of a small group of people being able to voice their ideas as if it's the majority and to stir shit up when it feels like it. Giant Bomb, as a forum and community, can do this - we just don't because the overarching mentality of this place is "we kinda don't give a shit." /v/, and 4chan to a larger extent, does pull this shit off on a regular basis.

[edit] Also, this site still isn't that popular, it just has an active userbase among it's regulars and casual visitors. TheVerge.com, a site bigger than Giant Bomb but still considered a small tech website compared to something like Engadget, can get a 2000+ comment section on an article about Android getting a small update on Samsung phones.

@CaLe said:

Wow, I didn't even notice until now how many comments that review has. What the hell happened in there? Did Brad talk about sexism or something?

He dared to give a really good game 5 stars. Can you believe that?

@CaLe said:

Wow, I didn't even notice until now how many comments that review has. What the hell happened in there?

Humanity.

Humanity happened.

Is a very popular what? Cheese? Car? Dance craze?

It's a very popular what? A VERY POPULAR WHAT? I NEED TO KNOW!

@Sweep said:

I liked Giant Bomb before it was cool.

*bans self*

Hey Sweep. How much does a hipster weigh?

AN INSTAGRAM! ha.

I'm sorry.

@AndrewB said:

@CaLe said:

Wow, I didn't even notice until now how many comments that review has. What the hell happened in there?

Humanity.

Humanity happened.

Indeed, nice going @Humanity

Fucking jerk.

@Bell_End said:

@Salbert said:

I'm worried about the growing popularity. I don't want the site to attract denizens of cesspools like /v/.

just glancing at said review comments, i think we are well passed that.

No. No no no no nooooooo. Someone linked to an actual thread in /v/ last night 'discussing' the review. It was filled with nothing but personal threats threats of graphic violence, and insults consisting of nothing but profanity and and a shit ton of slurs of every flavor, directed directly at Brad. It's honestly not even close.

@Orbitz89 said:

@Sweep said:

I liked Giant Bomb before it was cool.

*bans self*

Hey Sweep. How much does a hipster weigh?

AN INSTAGRAM! ha.

I'm sorry.

How can a hipster lose weight? They can let go of their Macbook.

That sounded funnier in my head.

@CptBedlam said:

@CaLe said:

Wow, I didn't even notice until now how many comments that review has. What the hell happened in there? Did Brad talk about sexism or something?

He dared to give a really good game 5 stars. Can you believe that?

Grab your torches and pitchforks and lets meet at the CBSi building in half an hour! Or lets wait until it gets dark to be even more dramatic.

The internet loves to go crazy when something is preemptively condemned, judged or deemed unworthy and then someone with access to a big platform goes against that opinion.

@Oldirtybearon: I'm not talking about a generic "hivemind" mentality, I'm talking about an internet lynch-mob mentality composed of gamers who feel the need to go on a holy crusade against reviewers they disagree with. Go on /v/ nowadays and you see people complaining about "casuals" unironically and getting seriously pissed off that someone disagrees with them. These are the lowest common denominator of gamers.

WTF is a " /v/ "?

I guess my gray hairs are replacing my awareness of stuff on the internet.

@TyCobb said:

WTF is a " /v/ "?

I guess my gray hairs are replacing my awareness of stuff on the internet.

4chans video game forum.

@Yummylee said:

@AndrewB said:

@CaLe said:

Wow, I didn't even notice until now how many comments that review has. What the hell happened in there?

Humanity.

Humanity happened.

Indeed, nice going @Humanity

Fucking jerk.

SPOILER WARNING: Click here to reveal hidden content.

x)

This is just like prom night all over again!

This whole thing depresses me deeply. I dont care if Brad was bought off, the people holding that opinion are acting just shameful. We can joke about the internet and how it's a hate machine, but it really is.

What does any of this accomplish? I'll tell you what: it gives a bunch of hateful, do-nothing people something to lash out at. Something to nonsensically demoralize until they feel they've elevated themselves to 'internet warrior of truth' status. All these people saying things like: "His lack of integrity must be questioned." Give me a fucking break. It's a videogame website, not the militaristic government of some impoverished nation. Get some perspective.

@TooWalrus said:

No. No no no no nooooooo. Someone linked to an actual thread in /v/ last night 'discussing' the review. It was filled with nothing but personal threats threats of graphic violence, and insults consisting of nothing but profanity and and a shit ton of slurs of every flavor, directed directly at Brad. It's honestly not even close.

Knowing the way /v/ works that thread will have 404'd by now, but I'd be interested to see an archive or some screen caps of it. I just wanna see it out of morbid curiosity. I want to know just how fucked we are as a culture.

@Mirado said:

Is a very popular what? Cheese? Car? Dance craze?

It's a very popular what? A VERY POPULAR WHAT? I NEED TO KNOW!

Cheescar Dancecraze is my favorite nu-polka band.

@Ravenlight said:

@Mirado said:

Is a very popular what? Cheese? Car? Dance craze?

It's a very popular what? A VERY POPULAR WHAT? I NEED TO KNOW!

Cheescar Dancecraze is my favorite nu-polka band.

And now my brain is sprayed all over my keyboard.

@claybrez said:

This whole thing depresses me deeply. I don't care if Brad was bought off, the people holding that opinion are acting just shameful. We can joke about the internet and how it's a hate machine, but it really is.

What does any of this accomplish? I'll tell you what: it gives a bunch of hateful, do-nothing people something to lash out at. Something to nonsensically demoralize until they feel they've elevated themselves to 'internet warrior of truth' status. All these people saying things like: "His lack of integrity must be questioned." Give me a fucking break. It's a videogame website, not the militaristic government of some impoverished nation. Get some perspective.

Uhh, what? Who the fuck thinks Brad was bought off? At this point, if any single member of the Giant Bomb community thinks that any review of any game is artificially inflated, they need to get their heads checked.

Do they remember how this fucking site got started in the first place?

@mikey87144 said:

@Winternet said:

Or very idiotic. One of those. (probably both?)

The more smart people there are that discover the site the more... angry and idiotic people there are who follow.

I'm a proud angry idiot who discovered GB before there was a GB. :D

@Sgtpierceface said:

@claybrez said:

This whole thing depresses me deeply. I don't care if Brad was bought off, the people holding that opinion are acting just shameful. We can joke about the internet and how it's a hate machine, but it really is.

What does any of this accomplish? I'll tell you what: it gives a bunch of hateful, do-nothing people something to lash out at. Something to nonsensically demoralize until they feel they've elevated themselves to 'internet warrior of truth' status. All these people saying things like: "His lack of integrity must be questioned." Give me a fucking break. It's a videogame website, not the militaristic government of some impoverished nation. Get some perspective.

Uhh, what? Who the fuck thinks Brad was bought off? At this point, if any single member of the Giant Bomb community thinks that any review of any game is artificially inflated, they need to get their heads checked.

Do they remember how this fucking site got started in the first place?

You mean Brad Moneymaker? Brad $hoemaker? I'll tell you what his initials stand for, and they aren't "Brad Shoemaker!" LET US SEE YOUR TAX FORMS MR. MAKER.

I love GB and it's really the only forum I've ever gotten slightly involved in. That said, one of my big rules is to never post in a review's comment thread and only read them for a laugh, especially for games like DmC that have a big internet cult following. This strategy has worked well for me.

@CaLe said:

Wow, I didn't even notice until now how many comments that review has. What the hell happened in there? Did Brad talk about sexism or something?

He pulled a Brad.

@planetfunksquad said:

@TooWalrus said:

No. No no no no nooooooo. Someone linked to an actual thread in /v/ last night 'discussing' the review. It was filled with nothing but personal threats threats of graphic violence, and insults consisting of nothing but profanity and and a shit ton of slurs of every flavor, directed directly at Brad. It's honestly not even close.

Knowing the way /v/ works that thread will have 404'd by now, but I'd be interested to see an archive or some screen caps of it. I just wanna see it out of morbid curiosity. I want to know just how fucked we are as a culture.

I saw that link and you're right, it had 404'd. Why does that happen? I know nowt about 4chan.

From the gaf thread:

Brad Shoemaker was an inside job.

i don't think it woud have a big impact on the community. We have a universal process on dealing with trolls, spam, ect.

also the fact that most of us speak properly and mature, it usually rubs off on others (disclaimer: not an absolute statement)

Wow, I never knew people cared so much about Devil May Cry.

@Sweep said:

I liked Giant Bomb before it was cool.

*bans self*

Popularity leads to intimacy.

@ExplodeMode: What video is that gif from?

That's funny. I just clicked on the comments link of the DMC review to see where things went, and it literally crashed my browser. It's most likely because I'm at work and they haven't upgraded their internet explorer version in 3 years, but it was still fitting. Things got ugly on there. Yeesh. Ok, now it just happened again! Something is fishy here. Wait....nope, our computers just suck.

@chilibean_3 said:

Popularity leads to intimacy.

FINALLY!

@BraveToaster said:

@ExplodeMode: What video is that gif from?

The last day of the Game of the Year videos.

He should go back to making shoes.

@Salbert said:

I'm worried about the growing popularity. I don't want the site to attract denizens of cesspools like /v/.

Thats why we have mods who know what they are doing.

It's like that one E3 podcast all over again when a bunch of kids around here first learned the phrase "corporate shill".

An unfortunate fact of life is that there just aren't any good communities of a substantial size on the internet. Too many meek individuals need a place where they get to be the tough guy and hurl insults over the least consequential things...like Brad enjoying the new Devil May Cry.

At least Giant Bomb has a small contingent of users that contribute interesting threads and discussions. But for the most part it is best to just ignore comments in general. Just like every other website.

I take solace in the fact that maybe less than 1% of the viewers of Giantbomb actually post comments (as indicated by that other article Patrick and others tweeted sometime last week). So really, the people like us who actually post are the crazy outliers.

@ExplodeMode said:

From the gaf thread:

Amazing!

@Andorski said:

@Orbitz89 said:

@Sweep said:

I liked Giant Bomb before it was cool.

*bans self*

Hey Sweep. How much does a hipster weigh?

AN INSTAGRAM! ha.

I'm sorry.

How can a hipster lose weight? They can let go of their Macbook.

That sounded funnier in my head.

Or they can stop drinking PBR

@Draxyle said:

I take solace in the fact that maybe less than 1% of the viewers of Giantbomb actually post comments (as indicated by that other article Patrick and others tweeted sometime last week). So really, the people like us who actually post are the crazy outliers.

@ExplodeMode said:

From the gaf thread:

Amazing!

Heh, that is pretty great.

I like how the thread has more people commenting that there are lots of people commenting than actually talking about the review

Devil May Give A Fuck