List your Top 5 RPGs

I love rpgs and would love to hear peoples top 5, for me the first that come to mind would be 
-Oblivion
-Fallout 3
-Dragon Age 
-Borderlands(it is original)
-Torchlight is also really fun to play.
Please list your favourites :D

- Madden 
-Gears of War 
- Halo 3 
-Killzone 3 
-Street Fighter 4

final fantasy 10  
oblivion  
mass effect (its pretty much an rpg) (PC)
dragon age (PC) 
Fable (the first one)

Torchlight isn't RPG, it's hack-slash.  Much like how Diablo isn't RPG to me.   
 

• Final Fantasy Tactics 
• XenoGears
• Chrono Cross
• Kingdom Hearts II FinalMix+
• Final Fantasy XII International Zodiac Job System

My Top 5 games from My Personal Favorites list are all RPGs, so this was pretty easy to answer.  

My Favorite Games of All Time ~ 2010 edition

This is a best of list for right now.  I tried to limit myself to 10 originally, but there were just too many unmentioned to I bumped it up to 20.  Of course, like life, this list is a work-in-progress.  [Newly Updated: Ha-ha, I look like such a Bioware fanboy.]  [Second Update: I switched some of the order around. Sept.-24]

	1. Star Wars: Knights of the Old Republic This was my previous number one game. It had occupied this spot since 2004. EDIT: Switched back to #1 spot after I replayed it recently
	2. Dragon Age: Origins This has moved to my number one spot in a relatively short period of time. EDIT: Dropped to the #2 spot recently.
	3. Shin Megami Tensei: Persona 3 FES This game enthralled me for hours upon hours. It touched me more emotionally than any other game.
	4. Mass Effect 2 A spectacular space adventure full of unique settings, engaging characters, and high action. Simply one of the most fun games ever. This is what we dreamed gaming would be like in the future when I was in short pants.
	5. The Elder Scrolls IV: Oblivion Replayability is what earns this games place on my list.

Shin Megami Tensei 3: Nocturne
Knights of the Old Republic 2: The Sith Lords
SMT: Persona 4
Alpha Protocol
Resonance of Fate

Mass Effect
KOTOR
Borderlands
Diablo
Fallout 1 & 2

-Planescape
-Chrono Cross
-Chrono Trigger
-Final Fantasy IX
-Final Fantasy VII

Chrono Trigger

Final Fantasy VI

Fallout 2

Icewind Dale 

Dragon Age: Origins

Straight from my head: 
-Planescape: Torment
-Fallout 1
-Fallout 2
-Diablo 2
-System Shock 2

" Wild Arms Threads of Fate (kind of an action/adventure rpg thingie) Legend of Dragoon Chrono Trigger Monster Hunter Tri (action/adventure rpg thingie too) "

1. Knights Of The Old Republic
2. Dragon Quest VIII: Journey Of The Cursed Kingdom
3. Mass Effect 2
4. Metal Gear Solid: Peace Walker(?)
5. Fallout 3
 
AH! HOLY CHRIST! THANKS FOR REMINDING ME!!
 
I had a complete brain-fart. I forgot some of the RPG's that meant the most to me!!

Starwars: KOTOR 2 
Mass effect (Whole series) 
Oblivion 
Borderlands 
Fallout 3

1. Dragon Age: Origins
2. Dragon Age 2
3. Mass Effect 2
4. Mass Effect
5. Dungeon Siege 2

1.  Dragon Age: Origins 
2.  Fallout 3 
3.  Mass Effect 2 
4.  TES III: Morrowind 
5.  Fable 2

• Pokemon Blue 
• Pokemon Silver 
• Pokemon Sapphire 
• Pokemon Pearl 
• Pokemon Black

1. Oblivion (also, coincidentally, my favorite game ever) 
2. Morrowind 
3. Puzzle Quest 1 (it counts!) 
4. Guild Wars/WOW tie
5. Mass Effect

Diablo II - Loot, loot, loot! Yeah, that. I've spent days and days and days in this game simply because of how fun the loot is. 

Persona 3: FES - I love SMT games, but this is just the right combination of combat depth, monster creation, and pure ass-fuckery (at least on hard) that creates easily the best experience on PS2, ever.  

Fallout 1 - This game showed me how open an RPG can be, and how to do it correctly: give the player a heavy incentive to do the main quest, but when they have free time the openness should be OPEN as all hell  

1. Oblivion
2. Mass Effect 2
3. Fallout 3
4. PSP 3
5. Morrowind

1. Chrono Trigger
2. Disgaea 1+2 (PSP) / 3 (PS3)
   
3. Fallout 3 / New Vegas
4. Diablo 2
5. Wizardry 8

• Arcanum
• Wow
• Stonekeep
• D&D Forgotton Realms Collection (Hillsfar, Menzoberanzan, Eye of the Beholder, etc.)
• Final Fantasy 9
• Wild Arms 1 + 3
• Breath of Fire 4
• Tactics Ogre [(PSP) The only reason this isn't on the list is because of how new it is to me)
• Etrian Odyssey 3
• Dragon Quest 5 + 8
  

"

• Pokemon Blue 
• Pokemon Silver 
• Pokemon Sapphire 
• Pokemon Pearl 
• Pokemon Black

"

Fallout Franchise
SRT: OG Saga: Endless Frontier 
Pokemon FireRed/White
Final Fantasy 8/12
Earthbound
 
People listing Mass Effect 2 as an RPG make me chuckle.

" People listing Mass Effect 2 as an RPG make chuckle. "

Persona 3
TES: Morrowind
SMT: Nocturne
Tactics Ogre PSP
Mother 3
 
SO MANY 3's ON THIS LIST

" @Zippedbinders said:

" People listing Mass Effect 2 as an RPG make chuckle. "

And when I see commments like yours I think of the many "facepalm" pictures on the internet. "

" @Zippedbinders said:

" People listing Mass Effect 2 as an RPG make chuckle. "

And when I see commments like yours I think of the many "facepalm" pictures on the internet. "

In no particular order: 
Mass Effect 2
Star Wars: Knights of the Old Republic 
Fire Emblem: Sacred Stones 
Persona 4 
Golden Sun: The Lost Age

" @phrosnite said:

" @Zippedbinders said:

" People listing Mass Effect 2 as an RPG make chuckle. "

And when I see commments like yours I think of the many "facepalm" pictures on the internet. "

I just have an incredibly hard time seeing Mass Effect 2 as an RPG when the only remaining components that resemble an RPG are superficial features that are present in things like most modern multiplayer shooters.   Ratchet and Clank has more RPG features than Mass Effect 2 does. "

When I started reading this thread I was afraid I was going to date myself but plenty other great "older' choices have been thrown into the mix.
 
My list, in no particular order: 
 
Final Fantasy
Fallout
Icewind Dale
Diablo II
Xenogears

western

Planescape: Torment

1.Diablo2
2. ff6
3.oblivion
4.the witcher 
5.baldurs gate   
these are the game I have spent most time with

1. FF 7 
2. Dragon Age: Origins 
3. Parasite Eve 
4. The Longest Journey 
5. Valkyria Chronicles 
 
HON MENTIONS: 
Shining Force, FF 6, KOTOR, Fallout 2

Final Fantasy VII
Dragon Age: Origins
Shin Megami Tensei: Persona 4
Lunar: Silver Star Harmony
Star Ocean: The second Story/ Second Evolution

" @Zippedbinders said:

" @phrosnite said:

" @Zippedbinders said:

" People listing Mass Effect 2 as an RPG make chuckle. "

And when I see commments like yours I think of the many "facepalm" pictures on the internet. "

I just have an incredibly hard time seeing Mass Effect 2 as an RPG when the only remaining components that resemble an RPG are superficial features that are present in things like most modern multiplayer shooters.   Ratchet and Clank has more RPG features than Mass Effect 2 does. "

You are one of "those" people, eh? I feel sorry for you. "

the longest journey was an amazing game, but not an rpg.  it's a point and click adventure game.

Skies of Arcadia

Resonance of Fate 
Persona 3 
Dragon Quest 8  
Final Fantasy IV  
Skies of Arcadia 

Knights Of The Old Republic 
Final Fantasy VIII 
Final Fantasy IX 
Mass Effect 2 
Deus Ex. 
 
Honorable Mentions. 
Dragon Age: Origins (and to a lesser extent, 2) 
Vampire The Masquerade: Bloodlines 
Chrono Trigger 
Persona 3 FES and 4 
Final Fantasy Tactics 

I dunno how to pick top 5.
Ill just mention 5 games I like a lot.

The Witcher
Baldurs Gate 2
Mass Effect 1/2
Dragon Age
Diablo 2 (at least in my definition of RPG :))

Probably a lot more l like, but these are the first that comes to my mind.
I think FFX and Fallout 3 are great games, just not for me.

• Deus Ex
  
• Baldur's Gate 2
• Mass Effect 2
• TES: Morrowind
• Final Fantasy IV
  

- Oblivion
- Dragon Age: Origins
- Fallout 3
- Mass Effect
- Tales of Vesperia

" @phrosnite said:

" @Zippedbinders said:

" @phrosnite said:

" @Zippedbinders said:

" People listing Mass Effect 2 as an RPG make chuckle. "

And when I see commments like yours I think of the many "facepalm" pictures on the internet. "

I just have an incredibly hard time seeing Mass Effect 2 as an RPG when the only remaining components that resemble an RPG are superficial features that are present in things like most modern multiplayer shooters.   Ratchet and Clank has more RPG features than Mass Effect 2 does. "

You are one of "those" people, eh? I feel sorry for you. "

Never said I didn't like it. I still played it and bought the first 3 DLC. I love the story and the characters and playing as my Shepard, it was a good game, just not what I could call a RPG. "

In no real order: