The GB crew are sent on an undercover mission. The FBI gives them 4 comical costumes. Who wears which costume?

I really like that Brad has always been chosen as the Priest so far. But how can Vinny not be a Bicycle cop?! Shame on you guys. :P

This thread has just gotten hotter.

Vinny is a gruff Italian from New York/Jersey. He's a frickin' fireman.

This seems like a good GOTY idea...

I think Brad has to be the nurse. Vinny would look fitting as a priest. Patrick in oversized firefighter garments looks apt for some reason, and Jeff is the alleged owner of www.guard.bike so he has to be the bicycle cop.

It all works out.

Father Vinny is of course part of a Mafia money laundering scheme involving church donations and the income from those wood bracelets with saints on them.

My pick is Jeff as a bicycle cop, Vinny as a fireman, Brad as a nurse (or murse), and Patrick as a priest. If these are not your picks you're wrong; end of discussion.

Brad has can grow an amazing Selleck stache. That makes him easy choice for the cop.

I'm glad to see almost no one agrees with me.

Jeff the priest.

@exiledastronaut: Because recently Jeff has been very jaded, harsh and critical of the market as a whole

I mean, it seems pretty obvious to me.

• Jeff because I've already mentioned
• Vinny cause he's benevolent
• Brad's lighthearted
• And Patrick stands for all that is right in video games

mhm mhm

This is important research.

Jeff the Bicycle Cop

Vinny the Fireman

Brad the Priest

Patrick the Nurse.

I can't explain any of these choices but as soon as I looked at the list, I knew them instantly.

I accidentally made Jeff and Brad both be the nurse.

Jeff is the Priest because I don't know, Brad has already proven himself as a decent detective so why not bicycle cop (plus 'stache), Vinny kind of looks like a porn Fireman, and Patrick is the nurse because that was the only one left, although I'm a tad iffy on that one because of the Outlast Quick Look.

Jeff the Nurse

Vinny the Priest

Brad the Fireman

Patrick the bicycle cop

Pretty good premise for a thread.

Jeff would make a great priest, think of the kind of firepower he'd hide under those vestments

The only sensible choices in my opinion.

Jeff the Nurse

Vinny the fireman

Brad the priest

Patrick the Bicycle cop

Great thread by the way.

No, that'd actually hold some ground... it's very common for nurses to become frantic and flustered when we bring in critical patients. They like the relaxed, time to think atmosphere.

Wait, why is this happening?

Jeff is obviously the bike cop. I knew that would be the popular answer.

Jeff's the super intense bike cop, Vinny's the fireman that always looks like he just stepped out of burning building, Brad's the nurse who takes his role too seriously and tries to look after all the bad guys, Patrick's the over-eager young priest that seems to really like calling people "son".

Brad has to be a nurse... a sexy lady nurse. Also, Jeff would be the fireman who starts fires just for fun.

@themanwithnoplan said:

Personally, I swapped Vinny and Brad, but your version is fine with me as well.

C'mon, Jeff as a nurse (presumably in drag) and Patrick as bicycle cop are just obviously the right answers.

As the creator of this exciting/completely unnecessary original content, here were my choices while I was drinking at the bar.

Jeff the Nurse

Vinny the Fireman

Brad the Priest

Patrick the Bicycle Cop

Alex the Accountant

@milkman: Those are mine exactly!

I love that alex only gets one option.

I could definitely see that as well. The only thing bothering me is stark lack of drew in on the action. I mean, we've always speculated he was an undercover agent waiting to be activated. He'd probably be the most qualified for the mission!

Vinny would bring joy to all his patients as a nurse, Jeff would turn his sirens into a crazy rap beat as a fireman, Brad would grow a sweet 'stache as a bicycle cop, and Patrick just kinda looks like a priest to me.

No Drew the Pilot option? What is this madness?

Fireman Vinny is the most agreed upon. All is well.

Vinny has to be the priest. Think of all the black he wears!

Likewise, how can anyone suggest anything other than Brad as a fireman? Have you all forgotten safety Brad? It's the logical next step.

Jeff as a pissed off bike cop just worked so well in my mind. Those lycra shorts!

That leaves Patrick as the nurse. I guess he is no stranger to a bit of blood thanks to all the spookin!

Are we talking about a male nurse costume or lady nurse costume?

I voted when I assumed we were talking lady nurse, but if we're going male nurse that changes things...

@bisonhero: I think when anyone thinks of Vinny they look through rose-colored glasses so it doesn't matter what he is; Brad definitely fits as a Fireman visually though.

Jeff the Priest

Vinny the Fireman

Brad the Nurse

Patrick the Bicycle Cop

Brad's obviously the Fireman, I want Jeff in the priest outfit (And not just because he does the best creeper voice), Patrick grows his hair back out and dons the goofy bike cop, and if one of them had to be an actual nurse, I'd go for Vinny, plus he'd look great in one of those little hats...

all the everything

@babychoochoo: Drew does not need a costume, dude went to the DMZ on North Korea using a Foreigner t-shirt and came back to tell the story! Drew is the backup plan to save the day!

@fredchuckdave said:

I wouldn't call it rose-coloured glasses, because that implies an element of nostalgia. Vinny continues to be a positive, reasonable dude, which is why he is generally everyone's favourite for every conceivable popularity poll. Also, as someone else above points out, Vinny as priest just makes sense given how much black Vinny already wears.

Jeff has to be the bike cop the takes his job way too seriously.

Bike cop like bicycle cop or motorcycle cop

because jeff should be a bicycle cop just for the compression shorts alone

Probably controversial but here goes:

Jeff the fireman: Just cause I imagine Jeff having a life long fascination with burning stuff and stuff being on fire in general, and this would allow him to be nearer to the object of his desire/fascination.

Vinny the Bicycle cop: Cause I imagine Bicyclecops to not be able to actually maintain an air of authority and end up trying to be everybody's friend and just giving you a warning instead of a ticket, their just too nice to be "real" cops.

Brad (male)nurse: Partially for his fascination with weird obscure diseases and horrifying conditions, and partly cause I just think he could pull off the whole scrubs look

Patrick the priest: thinking of patrick with his current look in a priests outfit talking to you in a soft calming voice calling you my son makes me chuckle, in my mind for some reason he's wearing glasses.

Edit: Oh and Alex would be the whino who lives in the alley around the corner

Jeff the Bicycle Cop, Brad the Bicycle Cop, Vinny the Bicycle Cop and Alex the Tax Accountant.

Vinny can't be a fireman, I think he said his dad was a fireman. That's a connection. It's supposed to be inconspicuous. He's a bike cop. He looks like a cop.