First game with a PS4?

Rocket League!

Even if you 100% Batman it's a quicker play. Both are worth playing, but I'd say get Arkham Knight finished with first.

The Witcher was a slow burn for me. Started playing it before Batman, needed a break, then finished it after I played Batman.

I got some bday money today and I was thinking about the same thing but I would go for few different games before Batman including Witcher. What about Bloodborne?

Still, on amazon looks like you can get a ps4 w. batman for $400 so that's pretty good?

Witcher 3 is arguably the best game on the console.

The fact that you you're seeking "strong narrative," solidifies The Witcher 3 even more. Don't forget about ROCKET LEAGUE!

If you haven't played Bloodborne you should definitely give it a look. It plays like nothing else and I thought it was far superior to Witcher 3.

bloodborne should be in the poll

Depends on if you've played the previous games prior.

Sorry if I wasn't clear guys, I'm all clued up as to which games are good (Bloodborne et al.), it's just that I want to play the two listed more than other stuff. Haven't played more than a couple of hours of The Witcher 2, though I know everything that I need to for the story, and have played the previous Arkham games (with the exception of Origins).

Bloodborne is the best game on PS4. Just play that.

I don't enjoy those games, sadly. They fascinate me, and I always watch EpicNameBro's videos on them, but find them too stressful and Bloodborne especially didn't strike a chord visually, something about it feels constrained/restricted....small?