On two quest so far I have noticed that I haven’t received every reward. For example, I finished a treasure hunt and I got every reward except the rare enchantment. The same thing happened on a different quest with an axe pommel.

At first I thought that they might just become available in the shop but I can’t find them there either. I have beaten side quests and received all of the rewards before so it’s inconsistent but it’s really annoying.

Has anyone else noticed this? Or is there something I’m missing?

Was it the treasure hunt where the treasure is found near that dwarven door, in the same general area where Otr is located? If so, I never received the rare enchantment either.

@rubberbabybuggybumpers: I did receive the enchantment for the one you’re talking about. The one I didn’t receive one for involves a shipwreck. I didn’t receive the axe pommel for finishing the lost souls quest. It definitely sounds like something is up.

I think I figured out the problem. You gotta upgrade your armor pieces to get the enchantment slots. Once you've opened up a slot, you can press square to go to the enchantments tab. You'll find the missing enchantments.