Should Portal be added?

#1 Posted by Mooshu (486 posts) -

It does take place in the Half-Life universe, right? But then again, it's also different from the other games and not part of the main series.

#2 Posted by MattyFTM (14420 posts) -

Since its in the same universe, I say yes.

Moderator
#3 Posted by Josh (61 posts) -

Same universe, different franchises. There will be a Portal 2, and if it's as successful as the first game no doubt a Portal 3 as well, not to mention expansions like Still Alive etc, etc, etc. It's not a game in the Half-Life franchise, so it doesn't belong on the list!

#4 Posted by Demilich (2598 posts) -

That would be like adding an X-Men game to Spiderman. Same universe, different franchise.

#5 Posted by JoshB (169 posts) -
Demilich said:
"That would be like adding an X-Men game to Spiderman. Same universe, different franchise."
its not as clear cut as that. I mean, I guess you could add an ultimate avengers game to the X-men universe. I mean, did you play HL2:E2? they are totally connected. I have a feeling too that HL2:E3 will tie it in even more, which gives it more of a possibility to be linked
#6 Posted by Demilich (2598 posts) -

Portal 2 confirmed. They have their own franchises.

Maybe not my greatest analogy, but you get the point. Just because technically speaking something fits, doesn't mean it should.

#7 Posted by Termite (2398 posts) -

Yeah, there are very highly related to eachother. And it's not at all like adding X men to Spiderman demilich, though I see where you're coming from.

They both make references to the other, and the story was obviously made with the other game in mind so I think they should both be connected

#8 Posted by Demilich (2598 posts) -

A better example would have been Warcraft, Diablo and StarCraft. There often have cameos and tie in, but are very independent of each other.

#9 Posted by xruntime (1920 posts) -

Yeah I agree with Demilich here....

#10 Posted by YuXing (65 posts) -

Nah, i prefer to think that portal is a seperate entity.

#11 Posted by hazelnutman (1097 posts) -

I agree with Demilich too. Instead of me thinking that they're in the same universe, I just think that they're just making a bunch of cameos/easter eggs/references to the other franchise.

This edit will also create new pages on Giant Bomb for:

Beware, you are proposing to add brand new pages to the wiki along with your edits. Make sure this is what you intended. This will likely increase the time it takes for your changes to go live.

Comment and Save

Until you earn 1000 points all your submissions need to be vetted by other Giant Bomb users. This process takes no more than a few hours and we'll send you an email once approved.